The Top 10 Communities in Indianapolis, Indiana

On ApartmentRatings.com, real renters have the ability to rate and review their apartment communities based on their experience touring and/or living in the communities. ApartmentRatings offers renters the ability to see what life is like at a community through a report card grade style format called epIQ. Every month, we highlight apartment communities whose renters have chosen them as having an A+ experience. 

This month we’re highlighting the top 10 communities in Indianapolis, IN, whose renters have given them an exceptional epIQ Grade based on their living experiences, as well as the management companies’ response to their reviews. If you’re moving to Indianapolis, IN and are looking for apartments, check out these top 10 communities!

Lakes of Windsor – 7251 Windsor Lakes Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46237

Interesting Features: True beauty abounds at Lakes of Windsor with picture perfect surroundings and a lush resort-like atmosphere. The property sits on 44 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds with 3 sparkling ponds. Active residents can take advantage of the basketball court, sand volleyball court, tennis court, and saltwater swimming pool, while families and pet owners can utilize the playground, dedicated pet walk areas, and bark park.

Verified Resident Review: “A great place to live. All of the staff are courteous. The community is well kept, and is very quiet. The neighbors are friendly. The community is close to many businesses, the highway and many other things.”

Buffalo Creek – 720 Buffalo Run Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Interesting Features: Set on beautifully landscaped grounds with five scenic lakes, Buffalo Creek Apartments boasts a pool, fitness center with a rock-climbing wall, sports courts, outdoor lounge with fireplace and grills, and the area’s largest dog park. And for avid fishers, the community offers a catch and release fishing pond!

Verified Resident Review: “Moving into Buffalo Creek Apartments has been an amazing experience from start to finish. The leasing process was smooth and straightforward, and the management team was helpful and welcoming every step of the way. They made me feel right at home before I even got my keys. The apartment itself is clean, spacious, and thoughtfully designed.”

Harbour Pointe Apartments – 4400 East Fall Creek Parkway North Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46205

Interesting Features: Harbour Pointe Apartments offers fun amenities, including a sparkling swimming pool with sundeck, sand volleyball court, bark park, and walking and biking trails all within a pet-friendly community along Fall Creek. Conveniently located near I-65 and I-70, Harbour Pointe offers easy access to downtown Indianapolis, IUPUI, Butler University, and shopping and dining in the Broad Ripple area.

Verified Resident Review: “Harbour Pointe has been a great experience and place to live. It is very clean and quiet and has a beautiful view from the balcony apartments. The staff is friendly and very professional. Couldn’t recommend this place enough.”

Estates of Creekside Apartments – 8055 Crossing Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Interesting Features: Nestled on the city’s south side near I65 and Highway 31, this pet-friendly community offers a sparkling pool, bark park, dog waste stations, and a family-friendly playground. Just minutes from Greenwood Park Mall, local parks, schools, dining, and shopping, Estates of Creekside combines modern convenience with suburban ease.

Verified Resident Review: “The apartments are nice and well maintained, maintenance is the best I’ve ever experienced at an apartment complex. The dog park is wonderful, my dogs enjoy being able to run around every day. The pool is always beautiful and well maintained as well. Overall a great place to live.”

ARLO Apartments – 5945 Arlo Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46237

Interesting Features: Boasting a sought-after address near the city’s finest shops, restaurants, and natural attractions, ARLO Apartments offer a beautiful saltwater pool with a sundeck, as well as outdoor community spaces and walking trails. For those who are environmentally-conscious, the community has EV charging available!

Verified Resident Review: “I am always impressed with the maintenance team and how quickly they respond to any concerns in the apartment. Their efficiency truly stands out, and they consistently demonstrate great skill in everything they do. Beyond their work ethic, they are also incredibly kind and respectful, which makes every interaction pleasant.”

Ninth Avenue Apartments – 4651 Mimi Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46237

Interesting Features: At Ninth Avenue Apartments, residents have access to plenty of fun outdoor spaces, including a shimmering pool, a bark park for the pets, and a playground for the kids! Conveniently located near I65 and I465 and just minutes from local shopping, dining, parks, and easy commuter access to downtown Indianapolis and the airport, Ninth Avenue provides both convenience and connection. 

Verified Resident Review: “Quiet community, feels safe no issues, any concerns I’ve had has been addressed quickly and professionally. Maintenance does a good job keeping the property clean, I see them out picking up trash first thing every morning. Super happy with my decision to move here.”

Arborwood Apartments – 6702 Trunk Way, Indianapolis, IN 46221

Interesting Features: For those who love staying active and enjoying the outdoors, Arborwood Apartments offers a variety of unique amenities, including a basketball court, two dog parks, a playground, a grilling pergola, and a catch-and-release fishing pond. Located near I-465 and Mann Road, Arborwood provides quick access to downtown Indianapolis, the airport, and nearby neighborhoods like Decatur and Camby.

Verified Resident Review: “This community is nice, the pool is nice and kept clean. There’s a lot of space for kids to play. The office staff is very friendly, as well as the maintenance staff. Any issues have been resolved immediately and correctly.”

Village of Bent Tree Bent Tree – 3210 Ramblewood Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46268

Interesting Features: Village of Bent Tree Bent Tree is the epitome of lakefront living! Select homes feature stunning cathedral ceilings and private balconies or patios with scenic lake or wooded views. Residents who like to stay active can enjoy the resort-style pool, racquetball and tennis courts, rock-climbing wall, cornhole area, and two fishing lakes. 

Verified Resident Review: “I continue to be impressed by the high quality of care the entire team takes in caring for the community. From the office staff to the maintenance team to the grounds crew, they truly strive for excellence. They are kind, prompt, and proactive with how they take care of the residents and the complex.”

The Oasis – 4900 Edinborough Lane, Indianapolis, IN 46241

Interesting Features: Just 15 minutes from downtown Indianapolis, The Oasis offers a comfortable, secluded community feel. Within this pet-friendly community, residents can take advantage of a refreshing swimming pool, a clubhouse with a business center, a bark park, a basketball court, and a play area.

Verified Resident Review: “Everything has been great so far! The apartment is perfect for my son and I as we transition into a new start! The staff has been great with getting me into the apartment as quickly as they could. Neighbors have been quiet and polite!”

North Haven Of Carmel – 4690 Haven Point Boulevard, Indianapolis, IN 46280

Interesting Features: North Haven Apartments offers superb amenities, including a beautiful lake and walking trail to appreciate nature right at home (you may catch sight of ducks, geese, and turtles!). The community also has a half-length basketball court, a swimming pool and hot tub, and an outdoor grilling area. Located just off E 96th St. and Gray Rd., living at North Haven puts you close to The Monon Center, delicious eateries like Cooper’s Hawk, and is in the heart of one of the most lively neighborhoods in the greater Carmel region.

Verified Resident Review: “Very clean complex with a beautiful walk around the lake. The team keeps the buildings clean most of the time and any maintenance issue is solved in just a few hours or a day. The amenities are always in good condition.”