B
B
Award Winner
155 S Poplar St, Elizabethtown, PA 17022

4.2

(168 Reviews & Surveys)
$1,240 - $1,485/mo

Reviews

4.2 rating

146 total reviews

(

121 Verified

)

Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFacts™ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Trending topics in reviews

Summarized by generative AI from text of customer reviews

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
Review Author Icon

Current Resident 990807

Verified Resident 2021 - 2022

4.5

1/25/2022

Everyone in the building is super friendly. I wish for how much I pay in rent, that things would be a little cleaner and updated. The paint throughout my apartment isn't a solid white and you can tell where it was just painted over any marks or patch jobs. The outlet covers could be updated as well.

    Property Manager Response

    3/14/2022

    We appreciate your feedback. If you notice anything that needs attention please make the office staff aware so it can be handled promptly.

    Updated Review

    Review Author Icon

    Current Resident 353969

    Verified Resident 2020 - 2021

    4.5

    12/10/2021

    Peach Alley Court has a great and safe community feel. This apartment building is old, but the staff is always making improvements and updates. It isn't easy to maintain a large old building like this one, so I truly appreciate all the time and care put into it by the staff.

      Property Manager Response

      3/14/2022

      Thank you for your positive feedback. It is so nice to know that the effort we are putting into making changes is not going unnoticed.

      Updated Review

      Review Author Icon

      Current Resident 792788

      Verified Resident 2015 - 2021

      4.5

      7/11/2021

      For the most part very good. Quiet and friendly. Would recommend it but the rent is a bit high in my opinion. Location is very convenient to stores schools. Conveniently located between Harrisburg and Lancaster

        Property Manager Response

        7/12/2021

        We are very glad that you are enjoying living at Peach Alley Court with our very friendly residents. We look forward to providing excellent accomodations to our residents that include WiFi that is included in the rent and a washer/dryer in every unit.

        Updated Review

        Review Author Icon

        Current Resident 591033

        Verified Resident 2018 - 2021

        3.5

        2/21/2021

        I love my apartment. It has a wonderful and unique character. The living room size is fantastic. I would appreciate the air filters to be changed more than twice a year to control the amount of dust. I clean and dust and within a few days it is as dusty as if I hadn't

          Property Manager Response

          3/14/2022

          We are very happy to hear that you love your apartment. If you are having any issues at all, please contact office staff so we can address any issues as promptly as possible.

          Updated Review

          Review Author Icon

          Current Resident 788651

          Verified Resident 2020

          4.7

          12/9/2020

          Staff is always welcoming and eager to be of assistance, however, some of the other residents can be unpleasant. Dawn is always quick to respond when needed, and the maintenance guys are super sweet..

            Property Manager Response

            3/14/2022

            Thank you so much for the positive response, we greatly appreciate it. We value and respect all of our residents and responding in a timely manner is of utmost importance. And we would agree that our maintenance technician is a super sweet guy.
            Review Author Icon

            Current Resident 842955

            Verified Resident 2020

            4.0

            11/12/2020

            Building is old so naturally has some flaws. The biggest thing to be aware of is there are bats that get in from time to time and office staff is hard to get hold of. Otherwise the residents are great and I do appreciate that the building is pet friendly.

              Property Manager Response

              3/14/2022

              Thank you for your feedback, we do appreciate it. Please make sure if you are having any issues that you use the resident portal so we are able to respond to all work orders in a timely manner.
              Review Author Icon

              Current Resident 835694

              Verified Resident 2019 - 2020

              4.7

              10/23/2020

              Love the refurbished factory look. Staff is friendly and accommodating. Safe property. Private parking. High ceilings and windows. Kitchen fully equipped and good looking. Elevator. Washer and dryer included.

                Property Manager Response

                3/14/2022

                Thank you for your positive feedback. We hope you continue to enjoy living at Peach Alley Court.

                Updated Review

                Review Author Icon

                Current Resident 705874

                Verified Resident 2019 - 2020

                4.3

                10/14/2020

                I love my studio apartment. High ceilings & spacious windows let in lots of light. An abundance of storage with closets, pantry & linen shelves. Having a DW and a W/D in the unit is a real plus. And the outside hallways offer lots of natural light with all the windows.

                Property Manager Response

                10/15/2020

                We are so glad you love your apartment here at Peach Alley Court. The high ceiling are such a wonderful feature of our apartments. Thank you for the wonderful response!
                Review Author Icon

                Current Resident 821799

                Verified Resident 2020

                3.8

                9/21/2020

                Beautifiul community nearby food location its a safe community that allow breeds and you cant not find a better quality appartment with dogs in elizabethtown or anywhere in central PA... this is great place to rent the manager is greatest manager anyone can ask for.. her vision for the apartment is appealing to the buyer's eyes.

                  Property Manager Response

                  3/14/2022

                  Thank you so much for the positive feedback. So, glad that you are enjoying your apartment here at Peach Alley Court.
                  Review Author Icon

                  Current Resident 790301

                  Verified Resident 2020

                  3.0

                  7/13/2020

                  Good location for my work. Lack of storage, and dated windows/building. Parking can sometimes be an issue. Management seems to try. Maintenance staff far past retirement age. Covid enforcement pretty much non existent.

                    Property Manager Response

                    3/14/2022

                    Thank you for your feedback, it is greatly appreciated.
                    Review Author Icon

                    Current Resident 704886

                    Verified Resident 2019

                    4.7

                    10/9/2019

                    The staff are quite pleasant , the apartment was very clean upon arrival, it's a pet friendly building and it's a quiet building. I love the elevator and the individual mail boxes. Having storage on property is nice too.

                      Property Manager Response

                      3/14/2022

                      Thank you for your positive feedback. The additional storage lockers on the ground floor are definatley a bonus. We are very pleased to hear all of your positive responses!
                      Review Author Icon

                      Current Resident 651995

                      Verified Resident 2018 - 2020

                      4.2

                      4/8/2020

                      This is a wonderful place in many ways. The staff is prompt and courteous with responses. There is a real effort to do things together as a community. The common areas are always clean. And, of course you cannot beat the architecture.

                        Property Manager Response

                        6/3/2025

                        Thank you so much for your positive feedback! We also just love the unique characteristics about the building from once being a shoe factory. Sincerely, Peach Alley Court Apartments
                        Review Author Icon

                        Current Resident 626559

                        Verified Resident 2018 - 2019

                        3.2

                        4/12/2019

                        Thus far my experience hasn't been perfect. My appliances havent worked quite right since I moved in (ie. Dishwasher doesnt clean, dryer doesnt dry, washer makes clothes smell worse). I'm paying almost a 1000 a month for a room that amounts to a large closet. Could use an appraisal of the actual value

                          Property Manager Response

                          4/12/2019

                          I am sorry to hear that your experience here at Peach Alley Court has been less than satisfactory. I do understand your frustration and in order to help you with your issues we need to first be made aware that you are having issues. We want your experience here to be a positive one and will work diligently to address your concerns as quickly and efficiently as possible. Sincerely, Dawn Dunlap Property Manager
                          Review Author Icon

                          Resident

                          Resident 2017 - 2019

                          2.5

                          4/10/2019

                          The apartment is clean and convenient the location is nice the maintenance staff is adequate however on a Friday evening when I had no hot water do to a bad water heater they did not come and take care of it until Monday I guess no hot water over the weekend does not constitute an emergency

                            Property Manager Response

                            4/12/2019

                            Thank you for your feedback as it is very much appreciated. We are very happy that your apartment was satisfactory for cleanliness. We always do our best to try and handle all work orders and concerns in a timely manner. We certainly may at times experience unforeseen circumstances but do our very best to always put the residents concerns and care as top priority. Sincerely, Dawn Dunlap Property Manager

                            Updated Review

                            Review Author Icon

                            Former Resident 124920

                            Resident 2017 - 2019

                            2.8

                            3/14/2019

                            I lived at peach alley court for over three years. I love the historic feel of the building, large windows, exposed brick and wood beams. Apartments are ok, newish kitchen. Bathroom needs a facelift though, tiles are cracked, walls are not painted when tenants move out (different shades of white), stains on the tub that I cannot get out! There was hair in the shower when i first moved in, seems like noone even thought about cleaning it. Courtyard is decent, looks nice in the spring especially in the spring but the 3 huge dumpsters take away from its look. The lobby is well lit and has nice furniture. The elevator is a different story, no tiles on the ceiling and exposed bulbs. Overall it seems like they are trying but it is just not good enough for the price. I think paying 850 a month should at least get you walls that are the same color, a clean bathroom, and a courtyard that doesnt look like trash.. Just my opinion.

                              Property Manager Response

                              3/18/2019

                              Peach Alley Court is an old building with so much character...not your typical apartment style living as it has wood beam ceilings, wood beams in living room and old world charm! As the new property manager here since November of 2019, my team and I have established a high standard protocol for our apartment move outs. Our elevator panels are in the process of being replaced but had to be special ordered. We do appreciate all feedback and will continue to strive to make Peach Alley Court a great place to live! Thank you... Property Manager at Peach Alley Court
                              Review Author Icon

                              Current Resident 613119

                              Verified Resident 2018 - 2020

                              3.5

                              1/8/2020

                              Nice place with tall ceilings and exposed beams. Rent is starting to be a little expensive for what you get being most things are some what outdated. My unit was dirty when I moved in and the walls were 3 different shades of white which meant I had to paint the entire unit, 13 gallons total to make it a place worth coming home to. Not sure about the other units but my floors are way off level which I had to buy new furniture legs and levelers to make everything look somewhat lever compared to the walls. I could add some more but I'm sure you get the idea.

                                Property Manager Response

                                3/18/2019

                                Peach Alley Court wants to thank you for your feedback As the new property manager since November of 2018, our team is striving to make the living experience here at Peach Alley court a very positive and pleasant one. Sincerely, Peach Alley Court Property Manager
                                Review Author Icon

                                Current Resident 595276

                                Verified Resident 2019

                                4.3

                                1/21/2019

                                Very friendly staff. nice and clean apartment . fair price for these conditions My entire move took only 3 days. the manager was very polite and patient, they helped me to do everything very quickly because I had very little time to move.

                                  Property Manager Response

                                  3/14/2022

                                  We are so pleased to hear that you had a very positive experience for your move in. Thank you for letting us know!
                                  Review Author Icon

                                  Current Resident 568921

                                  Verified Resident 2018

                                  4.2

                                  11/8/2018

                                  I have really enjoyed living here so far, the building is very quiet and everyone is very kind. The rooms are spacious and you get a lot for what you pay for in my opinion. Big windows allow a lot of natural light in and the chocolate factory creates an aroma of brownies baking outside! There is a washer and dryer in every room, trash and cardboard rooms on every floor, and everything is included except electric.

                                    Review Author Icon

                                    Current Resident 557262

                                    Verified Resident 2018

                                    4.5

                                    10/15/2018

                                    It's a very nice community with a good mix of people. It is convenient both by walking to the center of town and a very short drive to the larger stores. Our studio apartment has a washer/dryer which is a great convenience.

                                      Review Author Icon

                                      Current Resident 505195

                                      Verified Resident 2015 - 2018

                                      4.8

                                      6/25/2018

                                      I have lived at Peach Alley Court Apartments for 3 1/2 years and have greatly enjoyed it. The property manager (Dawn) has always been very prompt in responding and scheduling maintenance requests. Peach Alley has many plus's....location, a resident lighted parking lot, a secure and locked building that can be accessed only by those with a key fob, pets are allowed, I have met many other residents also residing in the building with me and the staff at Peach Alley Court Apartments have always been wonderful, kind and respectful towards me.

                                        Review Author Icon

                                        Current Resident 497836

                                        Verified Resident 2018

                                        5.0

                                        6/8/2018

                                        I had a very positive experience moving into the community at Peach Alley. My apartment was clean and neighbors were very friendly. I was very thankful that they accept dogs. The apartment is unique and full of character.

                                          Review Author Icon

                                          Current Resident 476240

                                          Verified Resident 2018

                                          3.8

                                          4/14/2018

                                          I just moved in Peach Alley, but so far the staff has been timely in addressing any move-in concerns that I had. I like that the building is quiet. The building and individual units themselves have a lot of character.

                                            Review Author Icon

                                            Current Resident 475643

                                            Verified Resident 2017 - 2018

                                            5.0

                                            8/15/2018

                                            The office secretary Dawn was very friendly, and made me feel very welcome from the first day. I haven't had any issues, and all the residents here are friendly, always say hello. If I wasnt moving to Florida, I would stay.

                                              Review Author Icon

                                              Current Resident 475077

                                              Verified Resident 2017 - 2018

                                              3.5

                                              4/11/2018

                                              It was good to be part of the complex. Minimal for the price paid, but I believe the third floor would have been better. Overall, would recommend this place to friends at the nearby college. Hope all well!

                                                Review Author Icon

                                                Current Resident 395578

                                                Verified Resident 2017

                                                4.8

                                                9/14/2017

                                                Peach Alley Court provides a convenient location and makes it easy to navigate to and from work, retail stores, and around town. The location is a safe area convenient to other dining and retail destinations in town, as well as to main highways for travel.

                                                  Floor Plans & Pricing

                                                  Studio

                                                  STUDIO

                                                  Studio, 1 Bath | 516 - 583 sq. ft.

                                                  $1,240 - $1,390

                                                  See Floor Plan Details

                                                  1 Bedroom

                                                  1 BEDROOM

                                                  1 Bed, 1 Bath | 620 - 756 sq. ft.

                                                  $1,245 - $1,485

                                                  See Floor Plan Details

                                                  Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

                                                  epIQ Ratings

                                                  What is epIQ?

                                                  The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

                                                  epIQ Report Card

                                                  In partnership with SatisFacts™

                                                  Community epIQ Grade

                                                  B
                                                  B

                                                  Renter Ratings

                                                  B+

                                                  Review Ratings (from 7 reviews)

                                                  Noise

                                                  4.0

                                                  Grounds

                                                  4.0

                                                  Safety

                                                  3.7

                                                  Office Staff

                                                  4.1

                                                  Maintenance

                                                  4.7

                                                  Neighborhood

                                                  4.6

                                                  Survey Scores (from 22 surveys)

                                                  Move-In Survey

                                                  4.2

                                                  Maintenance & Support Survey

                                                  3.4

                                                  Lease Renewal Survey

                                                  4.0

                                                  Review Count

                                                  A

                                                  Number of reviews in the past 365 days

                                                  7

                                                  Manager’s Review Engagement

                                                  C+

                                                  Percentage of reviews responded to

                                                  57.14%

                                                  Manager’s Review Reply Time

                                                  F

                                                  Average time to respond to reviews

                                                  96.29 days

                                                  Features & Amenities

                                                  Laundry
                                                  • In-Unit Washer/Dryer
                                                  • Laundry On-Site
                                                  Parking
                                                  • Uncovered Parking
                                                  Pets
                                                  • Dogs Allowed
                                                    Restrictions: Interview required. Comments: $250 Non-refundable deposit + $25/mo per pet (2 pet limit).
                                                    Less Info
                                                    More Info
                                                  • Cats Allowed
                                                    Comments: $250 Non-refundable deposit + $25/mo per pet (2 pet limit).
                                                    Less Info
                                                    More Info
                                                  Other
                                                  • Air Conditioner
                                                  • Cat-Friendly Community
                                                  • Controlled Access
                                                  • DishWasher
                                                  • Elevator
                                                  • Fitness Center
                                                  • Furnished
                                                  • Large Dog Friendly
                                                  • On-site Personnel
                                                  Show Less
                                                  Show More

                                                  Leasing

                                                  Peach Alley Court offers trendy apartment living in Elizabethtown, PA. Built in 1905, this historic building, once a shoe factory, boasts an open courtyard, over-sized windows, original wood columns and exposed brick walls. With easy access to I-76 and I-83, our pet-friendly apartments are convenient to Hershey, Lancaster, York, and Harrisburg. We are centrally located near Elizabethtown College, Hershey Medical Center and M&M Mars.
                                                  Show Less

                                                  Office Hours

                                                  • Sunday: Closed
                                                  • Monday - Friday: 08:00 AM - 04:00 PM
                                                  • Saturday: Closed
                                                  This community is managed by

                                                  AGM Property Management Corp

                                                  B+
                                                  B+
                                                  Communities
                                                  1

                                                  Questions & Answers (0)

                                                  Frequently Asked

                                                  How is Peach Alley Court Rated?
                                                  Based on 168 number of votes by renters, Peach Alley Court is currently rated 4.2 out of 5 stars.
                                                  How satisfied are residents with the upkeep and overall appearance of the grounds at Peach Alley Court?
                                                  Peach Alley Court is rated 4 out of 5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered good. The grounds are generally well maintained and attractive.
                                                  How effective was the maintenance team when resolving your problem?
                                                  Peach Alley Court is rated 4.7 out of 5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered excellent. The maintenance team is very responsive and effective in addressing issues.
                                                  What are noise levels like at Peach Alley Court?
                                                  Peach Alley Court is rated 4 out of 5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered good. The noise level is generally tolerable, with occasional disruptions.
                                                  How safe is Peach Alley Court?
                                                  Peach Alley Court is rated 3.7 out of 5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered average. The complex has some safety concerns that need to be addressed.
                                                  How satisfied are residents with the neighborhood?
                                                  Peach Alley Court is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is located in a very desirable and safe neighborhood with convenient access to local attractions and services.
                                                  How satisfied are residents with the staff at Peach Alley Court?
                                                  Peach Alley Court is rated 4.1 out of 5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered good. The staff is generally helpful and responsive, with occasional lapses.
                                                  How often does management engage with reviews?
                                                  Managers have responded to 57.14% of their community reviews in the past year.
                                                  How quickly does management engage with reviews?
                                                  Managers have replied within 96.29 days to their community reviews in the past year.
                                                  Who manages Peach Alley Court?
                                                  AGM Property Management Corp
                                                  What is the pet policy at Peach Alley Court?
                                                  Dogs Allowed
                                                  Restrictions: Interview required
                                                  Comments: $250 Non-refundable deposit + $25/mo per pet (2 pet limit).
                                                  Cats Allowed
                                                  Comments: $250 Non-refundable deposit + $25/mo per pet (2 pet limit).
                                                  What types of floor plans are available?
                                                  1 Bed, 1 Bath
                                                  Studio, 1 Bath

                                                  Contact Property

                                                  Peach Alley Court

                                                  April 2026

                                                  Sun
                                                  Mon
                                                  Tue
                                                  Wed
                                                  Thu
                                                  Fri
                                                  Sat
                                                  1
                                                  2
                                                  3
                                                  4
                                                  5
                                                  6
                                                  7
                                                  8
                                                  9
                                                  10
                                                  11
                                                  12
                                                  13
                                                  14
                                                  15
                                                  16
                                                  17
                                                  18
                                                  19
                                                  20
                                                  21
                                                  22
                                                  23
                                                  24
                                                  25
                                                  26
                                                  27
                                                  28
                                                  29
                                                  30
                                                  Beds

                                                  0

                                                  Baths

                                                  0

                                                  Under New Management

                                                  Claim your community to update listing information, capture leads, and respond to reviews!

                                                  Peach Alley Court is a 516 - 756 sq. ft. apartment in Elizabethtown in zip code 17022. This community has a 1 Bed, 1 Bath, and is for rent for $1,240 - $1,485. Nearby cities include Mount Joy, Marietta, Middletown, Mount Wolf, Hummelstown, Wrightsville, Highspire, Columbia, Hershey, Palmyra, Manheim, Mountville, and Swatara.