B
B
Award Winner
155 S Poplar St, Elizabethtown, PA 17022

4.2

(168 Reviews & Surveys)
$1,240 - $1,485/mo

Reviews

4.2 rating

146 total reviews

(

121 Verified

)

Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFacts™ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Trending topics in reviews

Summarized by generative AI from text of customer reviews

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
Review Author Icon

Current Resident 173304

Verified Resident 2015

4.8

8/10/2015

This is a very friendly and respectful community. Very pet friendly, and close to restaurants, bars and small town businesses. Extremely close to all grocery stores, auto shops, and attractions such as Mt. Gretna and 25min from Harrisburg

    Review Author Icon

    Current Resident 169439

    Verified Resident 2015

    3.5

    7/29/2015

    Love the apartment, the tall ceilings make it feel very spacious. Enjoy the washer/dryer in unit. Find the fitness center convenient but could use some upgrades as well as the courtyard. Parking is never an issue. It is within walking distance of shops and great restaurants.

      Review Author Icon

      Current Resident 169360

      Verified Resident 2015

      4.8

      7/30/2015

      I like the building. It has character that makes is different than others I've lived in. The staff is nice and helpful. My apartment is small, but it is what I can afford. I was able to bring my cat which is one of the reasons I chose to move here. I can walk to work which is a plus.

        Review Author Icon

        Current Resident 164991

        Verified Resident 2015

        4.0

        7/8/2015

        All of the apartments just got brand appliances, cabinets, counters, and carpet. The shower head was broken when I first moved in but after submitting a form for it to get fixed, it was fixed that same day. The staff is always available if you were to need any kind of help.

          Review Author Icon

          Current Resident 162632

          Verified Resident 2015 - 2016

          1.0

          3/9/2016

          It was also pretty bad how the snow was handled. I pay all this money and the parking lot wasn't even plowed... The office staff is rude. Rent is way too expensive. It takes 9 times for maintenance to fix something. I don't enjoy people coming in my apartment 9 different times.

            Review Author Icon

            ajp81270

            Resident 2014 - 2015

            3.8

            6/25/2015

            The building seems to be improving greatly recently, especially with making the apartments non-smoking. My low rating in the "neighborhood" category is only because this is Elizabethtown and has nothing to do with the building

              Review Author Icon

              Current Resident 162166

              Verified Resident 2015

              4.8

              6/24/2015

              I enjoy the apartment being within walking distance of many shops downtown. Not to mention the Amtrak station close by for making trips. The staff is exceptional and always willing to help and go out of their way to make sure you are taken care of.

                Review Author Icon

                Current Resident 157983

                Verified Resident 2011 - 2015

                4.3

                6/6/2015

                Building is kept quite clean and has a nice presentation. It is in a very nice and safe neighborhood. Kitchens are currently being remodeled. Staff is prompt in handling any problems. Building is non smoking. Building is mostly quiet and people are friendly.

                  Review Author Icon

                  Current Resident 157568

                  Verified Resident 2010 - 2015

                  4.3

                  6/3/2015

                  These apartments are fantastic with the exposed beams and features such as a washer and dryer. Utility bills are the lowest I've had in apt living. The manger at the complex is EXTREMELY helpful and has her residents best interests in mind. I don't plan on going anywhere new as long as I'm in Central PA.

                    Review Author Icon

                    Current Resident 155482

                    Verified Resident 2015

                    2.5

                    5/27/2015

                    The large windows are very nice. However, the appliances and cabinets, flooring, etc. are outdated. Overpriced for location and amenities. The on-site gym is dirty and looks completely uninviting. Overall, this is not a place I would recommend.

                      Review Author Icon

                      Current Resident 150714

                      Verified Resident 2015

                      4.2

                      5/2/2015

                      The staff has been very friendly throughout the whole move in process. The apartments are great and feel so much larger with the 11 foot ceilings. Food and fun are also with-in walking distance from the apartments. The large windows in the apartment bring in ample amounts of light and fresh air.

                        Review Author Icon

                        Current Resident 147584

                        Verified Resident 2015

                        4.7

                        4/17/2015

                        Everyone here has gone above and beyond to make me feel welcome and part of the community. Great building with lots of unique character. I would recommend this building to anyone else who wants to live outside of the cookie cutter apartment complex.

                          Property Manager Response

                          4/17/2015

                          Thank you for taking the time to give us your feedback. We are pleased that you are making Peach Alley Court your home. If you have any questions or are in need of maintenance, please do not hesitate to contact me, Dawn Higgins, at (717) 367-0741 or by email at dawn.higgins@peachalleycourt.com. Thank you again and welcome to Peach Alley Court!
                          Review Author Icon

                          Current Resident 134599

                          Verified Resident 2012 - 2015

                          4.8

                          2/16/2015

                          Have had a great experience at Peach Alley! Everyone is so friendly and anytime i have a service request it is completed within the next few days. I also appreciate that tthere is no smoking in the building which in an incredible plus. I would recommend!

                            Review Author Icon

                            Current Resident 133783

                            Verified Resident 2015

                            4.8

                            2/12/2015

                            Management at this complex is exceptional. The manager was very accommodating. The leasing process was painless. Very flexible leasing options. The pet policy is a plus. Would highly recommend this complex to friends and family. Great find!

                              Review Author Icon

                              khe

                              Resident 2014 - 2015

                              3.0

                              1/8/2015

                              We've lived here for 6 months and there's a lot more bad than good. Where to start with the bad? First I'll start with what could have been a great feature to the complex, the gym. Truly a cesspool of germs, snot and sweat. What appears to be a simple workout room is more like a breeding ground for the potentially sick. Not a cleaning wipe for months so we've had to bring our own to wipe down equipment. You'll clearly see drip stains of salty residues on the machines, free weights and mats. And who knows when the last time it was vacuumed or deep cleaned. Simply turn on the lights and view the filth. No cleaning crew. Disgusting. As for the apartments well those are a whole different list of headaches. First, the appliances are nearly 40 YEARS OLD!!!! The dryer is lousy and won't dry a large load for almost 2 hours. Between having the fridge on and using the stove, washer and dryer regularly you'll rack up nearly a $90/month utility bill. That's without using cool air/heat. Ridiculously inefficient. We came in to the apartment with a stained nasty tub and found out later by maintenance that the unit was never cleaned. Pissed us off. A few of the plug-ins aren't working. Winter parking can be a problem since they don't plow till the snows frozen over the ground with no salting or graveling. We slide out trying to leave the lot. Dangerous. The windows, though beautiful, are cracking peeling, ridiculously drafty and will suck cold air right in. I've never gotten my unit beyond 60 degrees on a 30 degree day leaving the place frosty cold and terribly uncomfortable. Don't count on getting enough hot water to clean dishes, laundry, and shower at the same time since each tank is half the size of an average household water tank. One of the features the leaser will pridefully express is the internet included which is TERRIBLE. Internet speeds are slower than dial up and cuts out all the time. It's so bad it even went down out during our leasing arrangement. What could have been a great feature is a cheap trick to lure college students to move in. Streaming videos is nearly impossible without cutting out and will take forever to upload. The designs of the units are enough to block even the best signals from the outdated internet setup. The routers are faced above the hallways outside of metal doors and metal studding in the walls making a virtual shield against wireless connections. Doesn't help that the entire hardware network is four years old. To get good internet will require your own self paid independent network on top of what your paying for this garbage. Many times we struggle to put stream music through the worst problem of all in Peach Alley, the noise, noise, NOISE!!!!! Walls aren't insulated so you can hear EVERYTHING your neighbors do. Whether they're yelling, talking in a low voice, blasting stereos or even having sex, you'll hear it. Units above are separated by wood beams and concrete so if they step anywhere you'll hear the ferocious teeth-chattering creeking louder than an alarm clock. This simply means you're level of peace and quiet is at the mercy of your neighbors. Since the leasers allow in anyone who has a pulse and the first months rent, your neighbors are either old folks (if you're lucky) immature college partyers living off mommy and daddy's trust fund, squatters, or trailer trash that scream there lungs out to every sports game Saturday, Sunday and Monday through midnight. So if you believe in an 8 hour sleep each night, it will never happen, count on it. We hear our neighbors walking above us in our bedroom, a neighbor alongside us working his telemarketing job till midnight and white trash on the opposing side yelling "F$%!!!!!" when his team's losing. Miserable. Much of these were issues we discovered AFTER er moved in. Despite what the leasers will tell you these problems are common from tenants so take the extra step by knocking on a few doors and asking folks who actually experience living in Peach Alley, not the leasers who have no experience with living here. All of these issues have been addressed several times with the leasers and the outcomes are as followed. ***Internet problems> Discussed several times > Admitted that a full system hardware upgrade is needed = Result: NOTHING ***Noise complaints about several neighbors >Said they'd handle it = Result: NOTHING ***Terrible creaking from ceiling by neighbors walking regularly during late night > Leasers will call a contractor to fix the problem= Result: NEVER HAPPENED To address all the negatives would be unfair without adding the few positives. The gym is well climate-controlled with little foot traffic and a clean bathroom. The windows are beautiful and provide a lot of natural light. The hallways are well climate controlled. There's plenty of parking. It's pretty quiet mid days. There's additional storage in the basement and the attic to each unit. Maintenance has been responsive to and completes repairs asap. We hoped for a quiet place and have been horribly disappointing. As for the value, $850 to a one bedroom unit in a 100 year old building with an environment plagued with loud neighbors, crap features and low keep up makes Peach Alley far less than valuable. If you prefer clean, simple and quiet, look elsewhere. Peach Alley Leasers, don't bother responding to this review as your lack of action speaks louder than words.

                                Review Author Icon

                                Current Resident 118104

                                Verified Resident 2013 - 2014

                                5.0

                                12/17/2014

                                I am new to this area, and I love living here. Our apartment is unique and has large windows. The building is secure with professional staff and maintenance. It is also remarkably quiet here considering they allow dogs. The building is in a convenient location with many things to do within walking distance. Nice place to live with good neighbors.

                                  Property Manager Response

                                  12/17/2014

                                  Thank you for your response. We are so pleased that you are enjoying your new home! Please do not hesitate to contact me at (717) 367-0741 or dawn.higgins@peachalleycourt.com if you need assistance with anything.
                                  Review Author Icon

                                  Current Resident 115631

                                  Verified Resident 2011 - 2015

                                  4.3

                                  3/12/2015

                                  I love it here. The apartments are a little small but have character. Eleven foot high wooden ceilings with beams, brand new kitchen cabinet doors, countertops and appliances, apartment size washer and dryer. A small gym. Security doors plus cameras. Four story building has an elevator. Management is very pleasant and responsive. Becoming a non smoking building next month. Location is great. Only one block from downtown one direction and one block from a park the other direction. Pet friendly

                                    Property Manager Response

                                    12/3/2014

                                    Thank you for your comments. We are so happy that you like living at Peach Alley Court! Please do not hesitate to contact me at dawn.higgins@peachalleycourt.com or (717) 367-0741 if I can be of assistance.
                                    Review Author Icon

                                    Current Resident 115606

                                    Verified Resident 2014

                                    4.3

                                    12/3/2014

                                    I love the apartment. The wood vaulted ceilings and wooden beam in the dining room give it such an outdoorsy and comfy feel. The apartment is located right off the main street of downtown Elizabethtown and it makes everything walkable. There is also a community multipurpose trail that is 13 miles long and marked at each 1/2 mile. I have loved living here in Etown!

                                      Property Manager Response

                                      12/3/2014

                                      Thank you for your comments. We are happy to hear that you have enjoyed your apartment and the local area! Please contact me if you have any questions or concerns at dawn.higgins@peachalleycourt.com or (717) 367-0741.
                                      Review Author Icon

                                      Current Resident 114807

                                      Verified Resident 2014 - 2015

                                      5.0

                                      6/10/2015

                                      This building has a ton of character, very large windows allowing lots of light in and my plants are going crazy! The staff is friendly & courteous. The other residents are always ready with a friendly smile in the halls and even outside. I'm very pleased with my apartment.

                                        Property Manager Response

                                        12/1/2014

                                        Thank you for your response. We are so pleased that you are enjoying your new home! If you are in need of anything, please do not hesitate to contact me at (717) 367-0741 or dawn.higgins@peachalleycourt.com.
                                        Review Author Icon

                                        Current Resident 112543

                                        Verified Resident 2014

                                        4.8

                                        11/14/2014

                                        I love the building! It is well maintained. Any issues have been resolved in a timely and professional manner. The people who live in the building are very nice. The free gym access and internet is a great perk too! I am extremely pleased with Peach Alley Court.

                                          Property Manager Response

                                          11/14/2014

                                          Thank you for the feedback. We are pleased that you are enjoying your time at Peach Alley Court. Please do not hesitate to contact me at (717) 367-0741 or dawn.higgins@peachalleycourt.com if you need assistance.
                                          Review Author Icon

                                          Current Resident 112189

                                          Verified Resident 2012 - 2016

                                          2.7

                                          3/2/2016

                                          Central location, free internet, gum on site are positive attributes. Negative attributes: old building with drafty Windows, rent increases more each year you're here ($20 first year, $25 second year). continual maintenance issues!!

                                            Property Manager Response

                                            11/12/2014

                                            Thank you for your feedback. It is very important as we continue to improve. Please feel free to contact me at (717) 367-0741 or dawn.higgins@peachalleycourt.com.
                                            Review Author Icon

                                            Current Resident 110833

                                            Verified Resident 2014

                                            4.3

                                            11/5/2014

                                            Nice place, good community, easy to get to from Harrisburg, parking is great, access to downtown is great Having to type 200 characters sucks I have better things to do than type on this site........Have a nice day yyyya ask a b d f lskdkdodkdkldkfdjklsajfdkslajfdklsajfdklsa;jfkdlsa

                                              Property Manager Response

                                              11/6/2014

                                              Thank you for your feedback. I am happy to hear that you are enjoying your new home and the area!
                                              Review Author Icon

                                              Current Resident 107865

                                              Verified Resident 2013 - 2015

                                              3.3

                                              7/14/2015

                                              There is no "community" it has run down and living on past reputation. The place is crumbling and the handy people are not that handy. The rent is expensive for what you get. The window have dry rot. The flowers are pretty. The exercise room does not lock so i do not feel safe there. I do feel safe in the apartment.

                                                Property Manager Response

                                                10/24/2014

                                                Thank you for your feedback. We are sorry that you are not satisfied with the work that was done in your apartment. We will address the situation immediately.
                                                Review Author Icon

                                                Current Resident 104517

                                                Verified Resident 2014

                                                4.8

                                                10/10/2014

                                                Cute apartments with a nice industrial feel, high ceilings, and large windows. My apartment has an exposed brick wall and a wooden-beamed ceiling. Staff is friendly. Located in a charming town and within walking distance to downtown and restaurants.

                                                  Property Manager Response

                                                  10/10/2014

                                                  Thank you for your response.We are happy to hear that you are enjoying your new home!
                                                  Review Author Icon

                                                  joshedmn

                                                  Resident 2012 - 2013

                                                  1.7

                                                  10/9/2014

                                                  You would think the idea of living in a renovated shoe factory would be a cool idea. It is, once you take in account the high ceilings, large windows and poorly designed apartments. Our bedroom was the same size as the rest of our house. WE all love big rooms but it was too much. The High Ceilings suck because don't even think about using your heater their bc your electric will 5x more than a house. I wish i was kidding. Management.... what a joke. 90% of the time she isn't even their! Almost had the floor above me fall in because the 1000 yr old water heater was leaking. The large windows are a big issue because you can't seem to find one that doesn't have a full draft of wind come through. Large enough that in the summer i wouldn't even need to open the window to to cool myself down. These places cost so much because of the high ceilings and keeping the historic value reliant. It is a nice apartment though. If you're a businessman who doesn't have to constantly stay at the apartment, its perfect.

                                                    Property Manager Response

                                                    10/10/2014

                                                    Thank you for your feedback. We are sorry that you feel you had a bad experience.

                                                    Floor Plans & Pricing

                                                    Studio

                                                    STUDIO

                                                    Studio, 1 Bath | 516 - 583 sq. ft.

                                                    $1,240 - $1,390

                                                    See Floor Plan Details

                                                    1 Bedroom

                                                    1 BEDROOM

                                                    1 Bed, 1 Bath | 620 - 756 sq. ft.

                                                    $1,245 - $1,485

                                                    See Floor Plan Details

                                                    Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

                                                    epIQ Ratings

                                                    What is epIQ?

                                                    The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

                                                    epIQ Report Card

                                                    In partnership with SatisFacts™

                                                    Community epIQ Grade

                                                    B
                                                    B

                                                    Renter Ratings

                                                    B+

                                                    Review Ratings (from 7 reviews)

                                                    Noise

                                                    4.0

                                                    Grounds

                                                    4.0

                                                    Safety

                                                    3.7

                                                    Office Staff

                                                    4.1

                                                    Maintenance

                                                    4.7

                                                    Neighborhood

                                                    4.6

                                                    Survey Scores (from 22 surveys)

                                                    Move-In Survey

                                                    4.2

                                                    Maintenance & Support Survey

                                                    3.4

                                                    Lease Renewal Survey

                                                    4.0

                                                    Review Count

                                                    A

                                                    Number of reviews in the past 365 days

                                                    7

                                                    Manager’s Review Engagement

                                                    C+

                                                    Percentage of reviews responded to

                                                    57.14%

                                                    Manager’s Review Reply Time

                                                    F

                                                    Average time to respond to reviews

                                                    96.29 days

                                                    Features & Amenities

                                                    Laundry
                                                    • In-Unit Washer/Dryer
                                                    • Laundry On-Site
                                                    Parking
                                                    • Uncovered Parking
                                                    Pets
                                                    • Dogs Allowed
                                                      Restrictions: Interview required. Comments: $250 Non-refundable deposit + $25/mo per pet (2 pet limit).
                                                      Less Info
                                                      More Info
                                                    • Cats Allowed
                                                      Comments: $250 Non-refundable deposit + $25/mo per pet (2 pet limit).
                                                      Less Info
                                                      More Info
                                                    Other
                                                    • Air Conditioner
                                                    • Cat-Friendly Community
                                                    • Controlled Access
                                                    • DishWasher
                                                    • Elevator
                                                    • Fitness Center
                                                    • Furnished
                                                    • Large Dog Friendly
                                                    • On-site Personnel
                                                    Show Less
                                                    Show More

                                                    Leasing

                                                    Peach Alley Court offers trendy apartment living in Elizabethtown, PA. Built in 1905, this historic building, once a shoe factory, boasts an open courtyard, over-sized windows, original wood columns and exposed brick walls. With easy access to I-76 and I-83, our pet-friendly apartments are convenient to Hershey, Lancaster, York, and Harrisburg. We are centrally located near Elizabethtown College, Hershey Medical Center and M&M Mars.
                                                    Show Less

                                                    Office Hours

                                                    • Sunday: Closed
                                                    • Monday - Friday: 08:00 AM - 04:00 PM
                                                    • Saturday: Closed
                                                    This community is managed by

                                                    AGM Property Management Corp

                                                    B+
                                                    B+
                                                    Communities
                                                    1

                                                    Questions & Answers (0)

                                                    Frequently Asked

                                                    How is Peach Alley Court Rated?
                                                    Based on 168 number of votes by renters, Peach Alley Court is currently rated 4.2 out of 5 stars.
                                                    How satisfied are residents with the upkeep and overall appearance of the grounds at Peach Alley Court?
                                                    Peach Alley Court is rated 4 out of 5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered good. The grounds are generally well maintained and attractive.
                                                    How effective was the maintenance team when resolving your problem?
                                                    Peach Alley Court is rated 4.7 out of 5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered excellent. The maintenance team is very responsive and effective in addressing issues.
                                                    What are noise levels like at Peach Alley Court?
                                                    Peach Alley Court is rated 4 out of 5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered good. The noise level is generally tolerable, with occasional disruptions.
                                                    How safe is Peach Alley Court?
                                                    Peach Alley Court is rated 3.7 out of 5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered average. The complex has some safety concerns that need to be addressed.
                                                    How satisfied are residents with the neighborhood?
                                                    Peach Alley Court is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is located in a very desirable and safe neighborhood with convenient access to local attractions and services.
                                                    How satisfied are residents with the staff at Peach Alley Court?
                                                    Peach Alley Court is rated 4.1 out of 5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered good. The staff is generally helpful and responsive, with occasional lapses.
                                                    How often does management engage with reviews?
                                                    Managers have responded to 57.14% of their community reviews in the past year.
                                                    How quickly does management engage with reviews?
                                                    Managers have replied within 96.29 days to their community reviews in the past year.
                                                    Who manages Peach Alley Court?
                                                    AGM Property Management Corp
                                                    What is the pet policy at Peach Alley Court?
                                                    Dogs Allowed
                                                    Restrictions: Interview required
                                                    Comments: $250 Non-refundable deposit + $25/mo per pet (2 pet limit).
                                                    Cats Allowed
                                                    Comments: $250 Non-refundable deposit + $25/mo per pet (2 pet limit).
                                                    What types of floor plans are available?
                                                    1 Bed, 1 Bath
                                                    Studio, 1 Bath

                                                    Contact Property

                                                    Peach Alley Court

                                                    April 2026

                                                    Sun
                                                    Mon
                                                    Tue
                                                    Wed
                                                    Thu
                                                    Fri
                                                    Sat
                                                    1
                                                    2
                                                    3
                                                    4
                                                    5
                                                    6
                                                    7
                                                    8
                                                    9
                                                    10
                                                    11
                                                    12
                                                    13
                                                    14
                                                    15
                                                    16
                                                    17
                                                    18
                                                    19
                                                    20
                                                    21
                                                    22
                                                    23
                                                    24
                                                    25
                                                    26
                                                    27
                                                    28
                                                    29
                                                    30
                                                    Beds

                                                    0

                                                    Baths

                                                    0

                                                    Under New Management

                                                    Claim your community to update listing information, capture leads, and respond to reviews!

                                                    Peach Alley Court is a 516 - 756 sq. ft. apartment in Elizabethtown in zip code 17022. This community has a 1 Bed, 1 Bath, and is for rent for $1,240 - $1,485. Nearby cities include Mount Joy, Marietta, Middletown, Mount Wolf, Hummelstown, Wrightsville, Highspire, Columbia, Hershey, Palmyra, Manheim, Mountville, and Swatara.