The Village at Mayfield Apartments
A+
A+
Award Winner
919 Aintree Park Drive, Mayfield Village, OH 44143

4.6

(428 Reviews & Surveys)
$1,560 - $2,101/mo

Reviews

4.6 rating

175 total reviews

(

108 Verified

)

Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFacts™ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Trending topics in reviews

Summarized by generative AI from text of customer reviews

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
Review Author Icon

Current Resident 793875

Resident 2006 - 2007

2.3

10/15/2007

Bait and switch

I am in the process of finding a new place. The grounds are beautiful, but the price for what you get is way too much. When I came in to look at the apartments, I was quoted $725. When I signed my lease, I found that that included a significant rebate. This year, they raised my rent by $125. This would be ok, if the market could handle it, but they are begging for people to move in. My neighbor moved out and found they were offering her apartment for $100 less then her rent. The first two months I moved in, I had problems with noise, an animal moved into the crawl space above my apartment. Nothing was done until I threatened to call my lawyer. Then in the spring, my air conditioning didn't work. Took them weeks to fix it. I rented a spot, but if I wanted to part on the surface lot, it was a nightmare. Don't move to this facility, or be prepared to move after 1 year.

    Review Author Icon

    Current Resident 873268

    Resident 2005 - 2006

    1.7

    9/30/2007

    Village Park of Mayfield sucks

    Absolutely one of the worst management teams I have ever met, especially the property manager -----. They just don't care about anything. My boyfriend and I lived there for two years before moving to Texas. Mold was everywhere and it was even coming through the carpet.They were not even willing to come and have a look. The last review is correct , they lost one of our certified checks too and apologize later , just to get the extra $50.00 late charge. Overall: bad, bad , bad and again bad. Never rent an apartment there !!!!!!!!!!!!

      Review Author Icon

      amygirl2029

      Resident 2006 - 2007

      2.2

      8/2/2007

      do not live here

      My boyfriend I were living in this apartment for 6 months when we started having problems. They kept telling him he wasn't paying his rent after he gave them a certified check! Then they would come back and apologize for their mistake. Now (8/1/2007) they have sold this complex to a new owner who is kicking EVERYONE out of these apartments so that he can renevate them. We lived next door to a sweet old lady who has lived here for 15 years and now has no place to live. Everyone is out to make a buck. He is kicking everyone out just to renevate them to be able to charge more for rent. They are putting tons of people out of a place to live. Who would want to live somewhere where there are people like that? On top of that, he gave us 30 days to find a new place. Absolutely ridiculous and I would NEVER live here or tell ANYONE to live here. Plus, the apartment isn't that great anyways for what you pay. The kitchen is TINY and there is a ton of noise.

        Review Author Icon

        poolaata

        Resident 2006 - 2007

        1.8

        2/28/2007

        This sucks

        I won't recommend this to any one. This is one of the most horrible apartments I have ever seen in US. It is just junk. Following are the reasons why one should not even consider this apartment.<br>a) It is old.. bad maintenance<br>b) Arrogant staff.. Even if you want them to fix a small thing, you have to call atleast 10 times<br>c) Snow removal is one of the worst<br>d) They cheat you in gas bill. They offer you 50/50.. I dont believe them.<br>e) They have carpets (some of them as old as 10 years)<br>f) When it rains, you can expect some flood inside your apartment.<br>g) Kitchen in too small<br>h) Very bad club house<br><br>

          Review Author Icon

          Current Resident 60261

          Resident 2006 - 2007

          2.7

          2/23/2007

          I wouldn't recommend this property to anyone. As a matter of fact, I work for a large company where employees are constantly looking for apartments. I always say, you don't want to live where I do! The condition of my building is very run down and dirty. The building generally smells very bad. There is one washer/dryer for 8 apts, good luck using them. The dryer is not worth putting a quarter in because it will not dry your clothes. Getting maintenance to fix something is a joke. If you are the type of person who wants to contact the leasing office everyday just to get one thing fixed, then this is the place for you! Snow removal just about does not exist and when they do plow, they plow the cars in. Upon move in, you should expect to kill 5-10 spiders a day only to have the leasing office tell you that it's normal. Terminex comes out every other Wednesday but that doesn't do much good. Parking is a nightmare on a daily basis. The only resolution given by the office is to buy a parking spot. The "billiards room" is a room with a pool table which is locked when the leasing office is closed. The cleaning job that is done to the apt prior to resident move in, is probably the worst cleaning job I've ever seen. There is pet hair mixed in with the paint on the wall because they were too lazy to clean prior to painting. The bathrooms are disguisting. Don't bring any furniture with you on your first day of move-in, dedicate that day to scrubbing, you'll need it. They also boast about how the gas bill is split 50/50, don't let them fool you. That bill is not anywhere based on your actual usage! So don't try to save money and keep your heat down, you're gonna pay regardless. <br><br>The only good thing about the place is the floor plan is nice and spacious. <br>

            Review Author Icon

            Current Resident 832411

            Resident 2000 - 2007

            3.3

            2/19/2007

            Decent place to live but rent is too high for what you get.

            Enjoyed my first years at The Village, which has beautiful grounds and great location. <br><br>Things now are much worse with owner-managed status. Owner showed his greed last year by getting some residents to pay half of gas bill for heat, though their lease specified gas was included in rent. Gas is NOT individually metered but is on RUBS prorata system ... unfair system. <br><br>Level of service is significantly down since Zaremba stopped managing the place in Dec. 06 -- insufficient snow removal, etc. <br>The new manager since last spring isn't interested in the residents quality of life and doesn't respond to problems. Another tenant told me the ceiling leaked badly and complaints produced no fix after 5 months. <br><br>Racketball/basketball court and computer have been down for months and management does nothing, though we are paying for these things. <br>

              Review Author Icon

              Current Resident 456784

              Resident 2007

              4.7

              2/12/2007

              EXCELLENT LOCATION AND SERVICE

              After living at The Village at Mayfield for the past 5 years, I am sorry to have to leave. I am transferring to California for a job transfer. If it was not for the transfer I would never leave this wonderful place. The apartments were managed by a local management company but are now owner managed and many improvements have been made. The buildings are currently being re-sided and the property is undergoing a facelift. The location is excellent (close to 271). The complex sits in the middle of a quiet residential neighborhood. It is the only garden style suites in the entire area.<br>The amentities are fantastic; swimming pool, 24 hour indoor raquetball court, 24 hour fitness center, business center, and beautiful party room for rentals. The resident socials are always great fun. The maintenance team is very quick to respond to service calls. The manager and office staff are AWESOME!! They are all friendly and sweet and very willing to address and solve issues. I would highly recommend this complex to anyone looking to move to Mayfield Village or Mayfield Heights area.

                Review Author Icon

                Current Resident 465538

                Resident 2005

                2.8

                6/6/2006

                Greedy and insincere

                The apartments are average. Many don't have a balcony/patio though. The upkeep of the property is okay. But my biggest complaint is with the leasing office which is loathe to return any money made in housing and car parking deposits. I still haven't got mine 7 months after leaving the place. The staff was not the friendliest and if you talk to them, they promise to call you back, which they almost never do.<br>PS - underground parking is hardly lit

                  Review Author Icon

                  jsmith79

                  Resident 2006

                  4.5

                  5/22/2006

                  This is the only honest review

                  I lived in village park from 2001-2003. The only Con I can mention is the high price of the apartment, $1100 for a 2bed, but the price of all living in mayfield is overpriced. The Pros are extremely nice upper scale residents in my building, using laundry was never an issue, the outdoor pool/hot tub was amazing, the landscaping is as nice as you could ask for, and the underground parking was a huge assett. also i saw alot of hot girls walking around, which is always nice. its very quiet and safe and enjoyed living there, you will too.

                    Review Author Icon

                    tri-c

                    Resident 2005 - 2006

                    2.7

                    5/16/2006

                    poor mgt. and lack sense of care to tenants

                    Before we moved in, we asked for clean on dirty areas. They never did anything as they promised. Requests for fixes always take long time, and the excuse is they're short of hand! It's a place where you pay that much and NOT get that much attention/services.

                      Review Author Icon

                      alias27

                      Resident 2005 - 2006

                      3.2

                      4/11/2006

                      has it's problems, but it's a good place to live temporarily

                      i think that we are paying a huge amount of money for the space that we have. my neighbor upstairs has two extra rooms and she is paying about the same as we are, maybe $50 more. i have been happy with maintenance, they have fixed all of the problems that we have had. the manager is extremely helpful, and one member of the staff is okay, but one certain lady who works in the office is extremely nasty and won't help you at all. whenever i need to call up there for anything, i just ask directly for the manager, i don't even waste my time talking to the other people. we don't pay for the underground parking, and sometimes the free parking is ridiculous. the lot gets so full that people make their own spaces and you have to go find another surface lot to park in, and then walk to your apartment. also, there are cars in the parking lot that haven't moved for over six months. one has two flat tires. we have told the management about them taking up the valuable parking spots and they haven't had them towed yet. despite all these negatives, i would still recommend these apartments if you are only going to be there for a year or two. it is in a good area where i feel safe and shopping is right there. the actual apartments themselves are nice, pretty noise proof and roomy.

                        Review Author Icon

                        Current Resident 530086

                        Resident 2003 - 2005

                        2.2

                        11/20/2005

                        Getting worser every year

                        Pros:<br>Still good landscaping<br>Cons:<br>Useless management and service, noisy neighbors

                          Review Author Icon

                          Cleveland09

                          Resident 2005

                          1.0

                          7/11/2005

                          Dirty and they don't fix anything

                          Don't move here. The place is dirty and smells bad... people smoke inside the building and management doesn't do anything.<br>If something is broken they do all their best not to fix it... once I had a problem with heat noise and they told me to put something more noisy inside the room so I would not hear the heat... quite amazing!

                            Review Author Icon

                            Current Resident 956251

                            Resident 2003 - 2004

                            3.0

                            10/27/2004

                            Management has gone stupid

                            Village Park of Mayfield *was* okay, with decent parking (not without problems) and good maintenance, but they have recently come under new management that changes the rules every 4 hours. Extending the lease and then moving out was a ridiculous pain as they kept changing their "rules" on everything, from how much you had to pay extra to notification periods. And the staff has just turned rude. Various perks of the property, such as monthly picnics, have been eliminated as well.<br><br>Aside from that, there are only minor problems with this complex. Dumpsters are few and far between, causing many residents to walk a long time only to find an overflowing bin of filth. It sounds like something you can live with, but try it for a year and you'll be annoyed.<br><br>Also the apartment buildings have one washer and one dryer for eight apartments. If you're told "you never have to wait to use it" you are being lied to. Also, the dryers are completely worthless.<br><br>Parking can sometimes be out of control in the "free" lots, with many residents parking on the side and blocking access. Good luck in the winter, when you can expect your car to be buried in snow for two weeks (that was fun) due to snow being plowed directly into the cars.<br><br>Overall I will still recommend this place as it is still better than others in the area, but it has truly become an obnoxious place to live.

                              Review Author Icon

                              Current Resident 873985

                              Resident 2003

                              3.0

                              6/6/2003

                              Be careful when giving advance money for reserving a room .

                              Be careful when giving advance money for reserving a room .

                                Floor Plans & Pricing

                                1 Bedroom

                                1bd/1ba - Den

                                2 Available Units

                                1 Bed, 1 Bath | 935 sq. ft.

                                $1,660 - $1,935

                                See Floor Plan Details

                                1bd/1ba

                                1 Available Unit

                                1 Bed, 1 Bath | 800 sq. ft.

                                $1,657 - $1,857

                                See Floor Plan Details

                                2 Bedrooms

                                2bd/2ba

                                5 Available Units

                                2 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,075 sq. ft.

                                $1,560 - $1,974

                                See Floor Plan Details

                                2bd/2ba - Den

                                4 Available Units

                                2 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,175 sq. ft.

                                $1,851 - $2,101

                                See Floor Plan Details

                                2bd/2ba - LG - Den

                                2 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,200 sq. ft.

                                $1,681

                                See Floor Plan Details

                                3 Bedrooms

                                3bd/2ba

                                3 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,400 sq. ft.

                                $1,753 - $2,074

                                See Floor Plan Details

                                3bd/3ba

                                3 Beds, 3 Baths | 1,370 sq. ft.

                                $2,092

                                See Floor Plan Details

                                Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

                                epIQ Ratings

                                What is epIQ?

                                The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

                                epIQ Report Card

                                In partnership with SatisFacts™

                                Community epIQ Grade

                                A+
                                A+

                                Renter Ratings

                                A+

                                Review Ratings (from 47 reviews)

                                Noise

                                4.6

                                Grounds

                                4.2

                                Safety

                                4.3

                                Office Staff

                                4.8

                                Maintenance

                                4.6

                                Neighborhood

                                4.8

                                Survey Scores (from 253 surveys)

                                Post-Tour Survey

                                4.7

                                Move-In Survey

                                4.7

                                Maintenance & Support Survey

                                4.8

                                Review Count

                                A+

                                Number of reviews in the past 365 days

                                47

                                Manager’s Review Engagement

                                A+

                                Percentage of reviews responded to

                                100.00%

                                Manager’s Review Reply Time

                                B+

                                Average time to respond to reviews

                                6.68 days

                                Features & Amenities

                                Parking
                                • Bathrooms With Generous Counter Space And Storage
                                • Parking
                                Pets
                                • Cats Allowed
                                  Pet Limit: 2
                                  Less Info
                                  More Info
                                • Dogs Allowed
                                  Restrictions: Pit-Bull, Staffordshire Terrier, American Bulldog, Doberman Pinscher, Rottweiler, Chow, Siberian Huskey, Bull Mastiff, and any breed dog that is mixed with any of the listed breeds.. Pet Limit: 2
                                  Less Info
                                  More Info
                                Other
                                • Choice of Bay Window or Picture Window or Private Balcony.
                                • 24-Hour Fitness Center
                                • Additional Storage
                                • Bark Park
                                • Built-in Microwaves
                                • Business Center with Wi-Fi
                                • Car Charging Stations
                                • Clubhouse with Resident Lounge
                                • Controlled Access
                                • Conveniently Located Near I-271, I-480, I-90 And Downtown Cleveland
                                • DishWasher
                                • Formal Dining Area
                                • Individual Climate Control For Central Heating And Air Conditioning
                                • New Kitchens With White Shaker Cabinets
                                • Online Resident Services
                                • Oversized Windows With Window Treatments
                                • Paneled Doors Throughout
                                • Preferred Employer Program
                                • Racquetball Court
                                • Renovated Kitchens
                                • Resort Style Pool
                                • Spacious Closets; Including Huge Walk-In Closet
                                • Wooded Or Courtyard Views
                                Show Less
                                Show More

                                Leasing

                                Welcome to Village at Mayfield Mayfield Village OH, a charming community of red brick apartment homes nestled on 18 acres of mature trees and beautifully landscaped grounds. Our community is conveniently located with easy access to I-271, I-480, and I-90. Enjoy the array of fine dining, shopping, and entertainment at Beachwood Place Mall and Legacy Village, which is less than 5 miles away.<br /> <br /> <br /> Our spacious on, two and three bedroom apartments for rent feature large bay windows, private balconies or patios, cozy eat-in kitchens and formal dining rooms. Some homes feature a separate den that can be used for an office or spare bedroom.<br /> Enjoy our resort-style amenities such as our outdoor pool and hot tub, 24-hour fitness studio, racquetball court and more! Take care of business at our Wi-Fi equipped business center.<br /> <br /> <br /> Renting shouldn't be hard . We do things differently to provide you with an easy experience from the second you start searching for your new apartment, with features such as a security deposit alternative, 30-day move-in guarantee, no-fee transfer and move-out flexibility options, no weight limits on pets, 24/7 phone support, full quality move-in inspection, plus online applications, payments and service requests. Make your move to Village at Mayfield Apartments today.
                                Show Less

                                Office Hours

                                • Sunday: Closed
                                • Monday - Friday: 08:30 AM - 05:30 PM
                                • Saturday: 10:00 AM - 04:00 PM
                                This community is managed by

                                Berger Communities

                                A
                                A
                                Communities
                                56

                                Questions & Answers (0)

                                Frequently Asked

                                How is The Village at Mayfield Apartments Rated?
                                Based on 428 number of votes by renters, The Village at Mayfield Apartments is currently rated 4.6 out of 5 stars.
                                How satisfied are residents with the upkeep and overall appearance of the grounds at The Village at Mayfield Apartments?
                                The Village at Mayfield Apartments is rated 4.2 out of 5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered good. The grounds are generally well maintained and attractive.
                                How effective was the maintenance team when resolving your problem?
                                The Village at Mayfield Apartments is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered excellent. The maintenance team is very responsive and effective in addressing issues.
                                What are noise levels like at The Village at Mayfield Apartments?
                                The Village at Mayfield Apartments is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered excellent. The noise level is consistently low and does not cause any disturbances.
                                How safe is The Village at Mayfield Apartments?
                                The Village at Mayfield Apartments is rated 4.3 out of 5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered good. The complex is generally safe, with occasional minor safety concerns.
                                How satisfied are residents with the neighborhood?
                                The Village at Mayfield Apartments is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is located in a very desirable and safe neighborhood with convenient access to local attractions and services.
                                How satisfied are residents with the staff at The Village at Mayfield Apartments?
                                The Village at Mayfield Apartments is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered excellent. The staff is extremely helpful and responsive to resident needs.
                                How often does management engage with reviews?
                                Managers have responded to 100% of their community reviews in the past year.
                                How quickly does management engage with reviews?
                                Managers have replied within 6.68 days to their community reviews in the past year.
                                Who manages The Village at Mayfield Apartments?
                                Berger Communities
                                What is the pet policy at The Village at Mayfield Apartments?
                                Cats Allowed
                                Pet Limit: 2
                                Dogs Allowed
                                Restrictions: Pit-Bull, Staffordshire Terrier, American Bulldog, Doberman Pinscher, Rottweiler, Chow, Siberian Huskey, Bull Mastiff, and any breed dog that is mixed with any of the listed breeds.
                                Pet Limit: 2
                                What types of floor plans are available?
                                1 Bed, 1 Bath
                                2 Beds, 2 Baths
                                3 Beds, 2 Baths
                                3 Beds, 3 Baths

                                Contact Property

                                The Village at Mayfield Apartments

                                April 2026

                                Sun
                                Mon
                                Tue
                                Wed
                                Thu
                                Fri
                                Sat
                                1
                                2
                                3
                                4
                                5
                                6
                                7
                                8
                                9
                                10
                                11
                                12
                                13
                                14
                                15
                                16
                                17
                                18
                                19
                                20
                                21
                                22
                                23
                                24
                                25
                                26
                                27
                                28
                                29
                                30
                                Beds

                                0

                                Baths

                                0

                                Under New Management

                                Claim your community to update listing information, capture leads, and respond to reviews!

                                The Village at Mayfield Apartments is a 800 - 1,400 sq. ft. apartment in Mayfield Village in zip code 44143. This community has a 1 - 3 Beds, 1 - 3 Baths, and is for rent for $1,560 - $2,101. Nearby cities include Mayfield Heights, Lyndhurst, Richmond Heights, Willoughby Hills, South Euclid, Beachwood, Woodmere, Wickliffe, University Heights, Euclid, Highland Hills, Willowick, and Willoughby.