Autumn Creek Apartments
A
A
Award Winner
5 Autumn Creek Lane, East Amherst, NY 14051

4.1

(195 Reviews)
$1,665 - $2,070/mo

Reviews

4.1 rating

195 total reviews

(

0 Verified

)

Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFacts™ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Trending topics in reviews

Summarized by generative AI from text of customer reviews

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
Review Author Icon

prelude67

Resident 2005 - 2006

4.2

8/16/2006

Enjoyed Our Stay!

I've lived in many large apartment communities similar to Autumn Creek and this was a fine place to call home upon moving to area. The location is great and much more convenient than some of the similar communities we looked at. Staff is friendly and informative. Never had problems with response for maintenace. Have read other postings about bugs and yes, had a bug or two in our place occasionally but who hasn't? Pet friendly which was important to us and our apartment was located in pet building located in quiet area off the main entrance. All, in all a good experience. Thanks!

    Review Author Icon

    happyrenter5454

    Resident 2005 - 2006

    1.0

    8/15/2006

    The Wicked Witches

    This apartment complex is the worst place to live in all of Western NY. The management has no idea how to deal with people and the apartments are not worth the hassle. <br><br>When moving out it was a complete nightmare made worse by the management. It took over 2 months to receive a portion of our deposit back. We were charged over $500 for damage to the carpet in which was in the same exact condition when we moved in. If they find a spec of dust in the final walkthrough they will charge you $30 a pop. <br><br>The management of the Autumn Creek apartments did everything possible to make our stay as uncomfortable as possible. I have lived in 3 other apartments and I must say this was far beyond the worst. Do yourself a favor and stay away, far away.

      Review Author Icon

      stevegmunion

      Resident 2002 - 2005

      4.2

      11/2/2005

      Didn't want to leave

      Lived here for 4 years- left when I retired and purchased home out of the area. The comlex manager always greeted me by name and took care of any repair problems pretty quickly. The apartment itself was great. Really big rooms with loads of closet space. I had moved out of a house before I lived here, and the apartment really felt like a house-- not a apartment. Thats another reason I stayed so long there. Great job of clearing sidewalks and parking lots during winters, and in Buffalo- that's no small feat. I have recommended this place to others

        Review Author Icon

        Current Resident 551970

        Resident 2003 - 2005

        1.5

        10/1/2005

        The worst apartment complex we ever lived in

        I have lived in numerous luxury apartments in my life and if luxury is what you are looking for at Autumn Creek, be sure to look elsewhere. There are two major problems with this apartment complex: shoddy construction and horrible (and I mean HORRIBLE) customer service. <br><br>Where do I even begin? The paint they use is extremely cheap. After barely touching it, it causes scratch marks. Ask for touch-up paint and they give you the wrong color (after waiting two weeks for it and making numerous calls). Light bulbs go out (that are their light-bulbs) and they ask you to buy the replacements. The ovens are horrible because they don't heat up properly. It can take three hours to attempt to bake a cake and it still won't be cooked right at that point. The toilets do not work correctly and we chronically had low water levels in ours.<br><br>As another reviewer correctly stated, the landscaping is terrible. Large swaths of grass are brown. In one spot, there is a bulldozer with a flat tire, with the shovel head pierced and embeeded in the asphalt. The little pond they have is filled with green muck and is never maintained. There is once maintenance person for 240 units.<br><br>Some people I know have had flodding due to cheap and inefficient piping. The rooms are poorly ventilated. We actually had to buy a radiator for one room because it was freezing in it, no matter how high we put the heat. The pool is rarely cleaned. They put a ceiling fan over the place where you would have a kitchen table, but no where else. Who wants a celing fan there? How but putting one in the den or master bedroom? <br><br>Have a complaint about any of these things? Don't bother because the complex is run by an obnoxious and tyrannical woman who blames the customer first. Pipes broke? It's your fault. Lightbulb out? You fix it. Calling too much for maintenance? We're going to charge you extra. It's literally a total disgrace. <br><br>Do not be fooled by the fake smiles you get when you ask for a tour. It is all show. Want to know what it is really like before making a committment? Ask some people around there. They will all pretty much tell the same story. So please, do yourself a favor, prevent high blood pressure, don't waster your money, and go anywhere else but Autumn Creek. <br><br>

          Review Author Icon

          ragingrentergirl

          Resident 2004 - 2006

          2.2

          4/28/2008

          All flash, no substance

          When we moved in, we were dazzled by the size of the apartments, and the fact that everything was new. Well, except for our carpet, which was pretty beat already. We quickly discovered that "new" doesn't mean "quality." The apartments are not well constructed. In the winter, we had horrible drafts and a complaint led nowhere. The windows are extremely large and hard to insulate, especially the sliding glass doors, which almost rattle in their frames. Our furnace and water heater were of the lowest quality and efficiency. In the summer, instead of drafts, we were treated to incredible amounts of bugs. I have lived in over a dozen homes and apartments, and have never lived in a place with so many bugs. Sow bugs, millipedes, ants, spiders; my daughter lived in fear of them. Two complaints to the office resulted in no action. The lawns were poorly cared for, despite frequent pesticide treatments and mowing, they were otherwise left, and we had brown patches of dead grass and mud nearly all summer. There are no garages available, and we have to compete for parking near our building. The topper is that, when our lease came due, and we were still looking for a home, they wanted to charge us $200 extra per month to go monthly without a new lease. The extra square footage isn't worth it. Edited to add: I can't let my toddlers play outside; the lawns are covered with dog crap that isn't picked up. Neighbors moved in upstairs and the noise is intrusive. I have had two work orders open for four months with NOTHING done on either; one is just for a replacement furnace filter! Why are we still here? Because of the outrageous penalties for breaking the lease or going month to month. That's all. Edited to add: Garages had mice! Discovered this in very unpleasant ways.

            Property Manager Response

            1/22/2008

            We are excited to have the opportunity to manage Autumn Creek for the new group of visionary owners that recently purchased this beautiful community. Our new community manager has successfully managed one of the largest rental communities in this area for the past 4 years, and has an impressive background in apartment marketing and management in Florida for over 25 years. We have expanded the office and maintenance teams, as well as our office hours, to provide our residents with exceptional service rarely found in apartment communities. Our experienced team of professionals will treat you fairly, honestly and with respect. We are truly committed to our residents and want to exceed their expectations. Our written Customer Service Oath is our written promise that if we fail to live up to our commitments to our residents, we will not only correct the situation, we will also refund their rent for a day. Our Customer Service Oath will also help our residents in the event of a Job Loss, Job Transfer, or House Purchase. Financial investment in the community included expansion and total renovation of the clubhouse, including all new furniture, to make our resident's parties feel like they are hosting them in their own home, which they can reserve free of charge; expansion of the 24 hour fitness center with new equipment; a computerized work order system to ensure 24 hour response time to service requests; free DVD movie and game rentals with new titles monthly; concierge services for our residents; the addition of a toddler playground; picnic tables and barbeque grills were added throughout the community; outside lighting was upgraded throughout the community; new snow removal equipment, golf carts, and a truck and plow were purchased to better serve our residents and expedite snow removal services; the construction of storage areas for the additional storage needs of our residents; extensive blacktop repairs; and a community wide exterior painting project. Landscaping included the addition of over 150 six foot blue spruce trees, numerous shrubs, flowers, and a professional landscaping service was contracted to maintain the lush grounds. Our pool project included expanding the sun deck to accommodate all the new pool furniture and lounge chairs, hiring lifeguards, and investing in a new innovative technology that eliminates the use of bromine and chlorine. This summer our residents would not have experienced odor, stinging or red eyes, irritated skin, or bleached out bathing suits while they enjoyed our crystal clear water. These are just some of the exciting new changes at Autumn Creek with many more to come. The goal of our energetic team is to offer our residents the best in customer service and a residence they can truly be proud to call home.
            Review Author Icon

            Current Resident 948307

            Resident 2005

            4.2

            8/7/2005

            Nice but pricey.<br><br>Pet apartments are located along busy roadway.<br><br>Fitness center crowded on the weekend.<br><br>Bathrooms are huge, with one adjoining each bedroom.<br><br>Linen closets in each bathroom are very convenient.<br><br>Walls are well-insulated from noise but the traffic noise in certain apartments can make the patio/deck unpleasant.

              Floor Plans & Pricing

              1 Bedroom

              A1 Plan (Lower)*

              1 Available Unit

              1 Bed, 1 Bath | 900 sq. ft.

              $1,665 - $1,715

              See Floor Plan Details

              A2 Plan (Upper)*

              1 Bed, 1 Bath | 950 sq. ft.

              $1,720 - $1,770

              See Floor Plan Details

              2 Bedrooms

              C2 Plan (Upper)*

              4 Available Units

              2 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,290 sq. ft.

              $2,008 - $2,058

              See Floor Plan Details

              C1 Plan (Lower)*

              4 Available Units

              2 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,240 sq. ft.

              $2,020 - $2,070

              See Floor Plan Details

              B1 Plan (Lower)*

              2 Beds, 1.5 Baths | 1,090 sq. ft.

              $1,847 - $1,882

              See Floor Plan Details

              B2 Plan (Upper)*

              2 Beds, 1.5 Baths | 1,190 sq. ft.

              $1,873 - $1,908

              See Floor Plan Details

              Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

              epIQ Ratings

              What is epIQ?

              The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

              epIQ Report Card

              In partnership with SatisFacts™

              Community epIQ Grade

              A
              A

              Renter Ratings

              A

              Review Ratings (from 23 reviews)

              Noise

              4.8

              Grounds

              4.6

              Safety

              4.5

              Office Staff

              4.8

              Maintenance

              4.6

              Neighborhood

              4.4

              Survey Scores N/A

              Review Count

              A

              Number of reviews in the past 365 days

              23

              Manager’s Review Engagement

              A+

              Percentage of reviews responded to

              100.00%

              Manager’s Review Reply Time

              A

              Average time to respond to reviews

              2.17 days

              Features & Amenities

              Laundry
              • Washer/Dryer
              Parking
              • Garage
              • Parking
              Pets
              • Dogs Allowed
                Restrictions: We know that pets are furry family members and we gladly welcome your dogs and cats. We're sure they will love it here! If you choose to bring a pet there is a non-refundable Pet Charge of $300 for the first pet and $200 for each additional pet. The monthly pet charge is $30/month for 1st pet and $25/month for each additional. For each pet weighing 50 lbs. or more there is an additional $100 non-refundable pet charge. We do have weight limits for certain apartments and some breed restrictions. Dog breeds known for aggression are prohibited. This includes but is not limited to: Pit-Bulls, American Staffordshire Terriers, Chow Chows, Rottweilers, Dobermans, Akitas, Dalmatians, Siberian Huskies, Malamutes, Mastiffs, American Bulldogs, Hybrid Wolves or other dog breeds known for their aggression. No mixes of these breeds will be allowed. If you have any questions we encourage you to call our office. *All fees subject to change. Pet Limit: 3. Comments: Dog breeds known for aggression are prohibited. This includes but is not limited to: Pit-Bulls, American Staffordshire Terriers, Chow Chows, Rottweilers, Dobermans, Akitas, Dalmatians, Siberian Huskies, Mastiffs, American Bulldogs, Hybrid W
                Less Info
                More Info
              • Cats Allowed
                Restrictions: We know that pets are furry family members and we gladly welcome your dogs and cats. We're sure they will love it here! If you choose to bring a pet there is a non-refundable Pet Charge of $300 for the first pet and $200 for each additional pet. The monthly pet charge is $30/month for 1st pet and $25/month for each additional. For each pet weighing 50 lbs. or more there is an additional $100 non-refundable pet charge. We do have weight limits for certain apartments and some breed restrictions. Dog breeds known for aggression are prohibited. This includes but is not limited to: Pit-Bulls, American Staffordshire Terriers, Chow Chows, Rottweilers, Dobermans, Akitas, Dalmatians, Siberian Huskies, Malamutes, Mastiffs, American Bulldogs, Hybrid Wolves or other dog breeds known for their aggression. No mixes of these breeds will be allowed. If you have any questions we encourage you to call our office. *All fees subject to change. Pet Limit: 3. Comments: We know that pets are furry family members and we gladly welcome your dogs and cats. We're sure they will love it here!
                Less Info
                More Info
              Other
              • 24-Hour Customer Service
              • 24-Hour Emergency Maintenance
              • 24-Hour Fitness Center
              • Additional Storage
              • Air Conditioning
              • Balcony or Patio
              • Basketball Court
              • Business Center
              • Cat Friendly
              • Central Heat and Air
              • Clubhouse
              • Concierge
              • Controlled Access
              • Dishwasher
              • Dodge Elementary, Casey Middle and Williamsville High School
              • Dog Park
              • Energy Star Certified
              • Fireplace
              • Furnished Available
              • Kids Activity Zone Playground
              • Koi Pond with Waterfall
              • Large Dog Friendly
              • Limited Package Acceptance
              • On-Site Maintenance
              • On-Site Management
              • Online Resident Services
              • Paw Spa
              • Picnic Area with Grill
              • Plank Flooring
              • Private Entry
              • Resident Social Events
              • Salt Water Swimming Pool
              • Scenic Pond and Gazebo
              • Smoke Free Community
              • Stainless Steel Appliances
              • Storage Space
              • Sundeck
              • TV Lounge
              • USB Outlets
              • Walk In Closets
              Show Less
              Show More

              Leasing

              At Autumn Creek Apartments you will appreciate all of the comforts of home in your very own 1 or 2-bedroom home. With up to 1,290 square feet of living space, open-concept layouts, large walk-in closets, and storage space, you are sure to find a place for everything.
              Show Less

              Office Hours

              • Sunday: Closed
              • Monday - Friday: 09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
              • Saturday: Closed
              This community is managed by

              BMW Mgmt Company

              A
              A
              Communities
              4

              Questions & Answers (0)

              Frequently Asked

              How is Autumn Creek Apartments Rated?
              Based on 195 number of votes by renters, Autumn Creek Apartments is currently rated 4.1 out of 5 stars.
              How satisfied are residents with the upkeep and overall appearance of the grounds at Autumn Creek Apartments?
              Autumn Creek Apartments is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered excellent. The grounds are well kept and beautiful.
              How effective was the maintenance team when resolving your problem?
              Autumn Creek Apartments is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered excellent. The maintenance team is very responsive and effective in addressing issues.
              What are noise levels like at Autumn Creek Apartments?
              Autumn Creek Apartments is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered excellent. The noise level is consistently low and does not cause any disturbances.
              How safe is Autumn Creek Apartments?
              Autumn Creek Apartments is rated 4.5 out of 5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is very secure and safe, with no major safety concerns.
              How satisfied are residents with the neighborhood?
              Autumn Creek Apartments is rated 4.4 out of 5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered good. The complex is located in a generally safe and desirable neighborhood with good access to local attractions and services.
              How satisfied are residents with the staff at Autumn Creek Apartments?
              Autumn Creek Apartments is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered excellent. The staff is extremely helpful and responsive to resident needs.
              How often does management engage with reviews?
              Managers have responded to 100% of their community reviews in the past year.
              How quickly does management engage with reviews?
              Managers have replied within 2.17 days to their community reviews in the past year.
              Who manages Autumn Creek Apartments?
              BMW Mgmt Company
              What is the pet policy at Autumn Creek Apartments?
              Dogs Allowed
              Restrictions: We know that pets are furry family members and we gladly welcome your dogs and cats. We're sure they will love it here! If you choose to bring a pet there is a non-refundable Pet Charge of $300 for the first pet and $200 for each additional pet. The monthly pet charge is $30/month for 1st pet and $25/month for each additional. For each pet weighing 50 lbs. or more there is an additional $100 non-refundable pet charge. We do have weight limits for certain apartments and some breed restrictions. Dog breeds known for aggression are prohibited. This includes but is not limited to: Pit-Bulls, American Staffordshire Terriers, Chow Chows, Rottweilers, Dobermans, Akitas, Dalmatians, Siberian Huskies, Malamutes, Mastiffs, American Bulldogs, Hybrid Wolves or other dog breeds known for their aggression. No mixes of these breeds will be allowed. If you have any questions we encourage you to call our office. *All fees subject to change
              Pet Limit: 3
              Comments: Dog breeds known for aggression are prohibited. This includes but is not limited to: Pit-Bulls, American Staffordshire Terriers, Chow Chows, Rottweilers, Dobermans, Akitas, Dalmatians, Siberian Huskies, Mastiffs, American Bulldogs, Hybrid W
              Cats Allowed
              Restrictions: We know that pets are furry family members and we gladly welcome your dogs and cats. We're sure they will love it here! If you choose to bring a pet there is a non-refundable Pet Charge of $300 for the first pet and $200 for each additional pet. The monthly pet charge is $30/month for 1st pet and $25/month for each additional. For each pet weighing 50 lbs. or more there is an additional $100 non-refundable pet charge. We do have weight limits for certain apartments and some breed restrictions. Dog breeds known for aggression are prohibited. This includes but is not limited to: Pit-Bulls, American Staffordshire Terriers, Chow Chows, Rottweilers, Dobermans, Akitas, Dalmatians, Siberian Huskies, Malamutes, Mastiffs, American Bulldogs, Hybrid Wolves or other dog breeds known for their aggression. No mixes of these breeds will be allowed. If you have any questions we encourage you to call our office. *All fees subject to change
              Pet Limit: 3
              Comments: We know that pets are furry family members and we gladly welcome your dogs and cats. We're sure they will love it here!
              What types of floor plans are available?
              1 Bed, 1 Bath
              2 Beds, 1.5 Baths
              2 Beds, 2 Baths

              Contact Property

              April 2026

              Sun
              Mon
              Tue
              Wed
              Thu
              Fri
              Sat
              1
              2
              3
              4
              5
              6
              7
              8
              9
              10
              11
              12
              13
              14
              15
              16
              17
              18
              19
              20
              21
              22
              23
              24
              25
              26
              27
              28
              29
              30
              Beds

              0

              Baths

              0

              Under New Management

              Claim your community to update listing information, capture leads, and respond to reviews!

              Autumn Creek Apartments is a 900 - 1,290 sq. ft. apartment in East Amherst in zip code 14051. This community has a 1 - 2 Beds, 1 - 2 Baths, and is for rent for $1,665 - $2,070. Nearby cities include Getzville, Williamsville, Amherst, Wheatfield, Tonawanda, North Tonawanda, Lockport, Cheektowaga, Lancaster, Kenmore, Depew, Akron, and Buffalo.