Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley
A+
A+
Award Winner
7212 Carlton Arms Drive , New Port Richey, FL 34653

4.7

(1574 Reviews & Surveys)
$1,205 - $2,127/mo

Reviews

4.7 rating

429 total reviews

(

370 Verified

)

Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFacts™ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Trending topics in reviews

Summarized by generative AI from text of customer reviews

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating

Updated Review

Review Author Icon

Current Resident 1334903

Verified Resident 2017 - 2026

5.0

3/30/2026

Living here from 2002. But I lived here from 2002, then left in 2018, but returned in 2022. You don't realize what you have, till you move. This place is just right. For families, or singles rent is great.

    Property Manager Response

    3/31/2026

    We are so glad to have you back and hopefully for many more years to come! Hope seeing you at the fitness center Grand Opening this week!
    Review Author Icon

    Current Resident 1413200

    Verified Resident 2026

    4.3

    3/30/2026

    Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is a wonderful apartment community that truly stands out for its peaceful atmosphere and beautifully maintained surroundings. From the moment you enter the property, you can see the care that goes into the landscaping, with lush greenery, scenic water features, and a layout that feels open and relaxing. It creates a calm, inviting environment that makes coming home something to look forward to every day. One of the most impressive aspects of the community is the professionalism and friendliness of the staff. The leasing team is welcoming, knowledgeable, and always ready to assist residents with any questions or needs. The maintenance team is equally exceptional, known for being prompt, efficient, and respectful, which adds a strong sense of comfort and reliability to living here. Residents also enjoy a strong sense of community, where neighbors are friendly and the overall environment feels safe and well cared for. The amenities are thoughtfully maintained and provide great opportunities to relax and enjoy your surroundings. Overall, Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley offers a high-quality living experience that combines comfort, beauty, and excellent service. It's an ideal place for anyone looking for a peaceful, well-managed community to call home.

      Property Manager Response

      3/31/2026

      Thank you so much for taking the time to share your positive experience here. We are happy to have you as one of our valued residents. Hope to seeing you this week at the Grand Opening of the Fitness Center!
      Review Author Icon

      Current Resident 1412846

      Verified Resident 2015 - 2026

      4.0

      3/28/2026

      We have lived here multiple times and always come back. It really feels like home for us and we appreciate the upkeep and rent prices. The community is always nice looking and enjoyable to walk around in.

        Property Manager Response

        3/30/2026

        Thank you for always coming back to us! We are happy to have you here!

        Updated Review

        Review Author Icon

        Current Resident 1349629

        Verified Resident 2023 - 2026

        4.8

        3/26/2026

        In my opinion Carlton Arms is a good community to live in. They have great amenities and laundry service which I might add is very reasonably priced I have rented apartments all over this country and I must say this place is the best by far. Thank you.

          Property Manager Response

          3/27/2026

          Thank you for your honest review, we hope to see you during the Grand Opening of the Gym next week!

          Updated Review

          Review Author Icon

          Current Resident 1239503

          Verified Resident 2021 - 2026

          4.0

          3/21/2026

          I've been in Carlton Arms for 5 years now. They are making some great upgrades and changes in the community. Looking forward to using the new improved and bigger gym. The playground was redone but still leaves something to be desired. Friendly community with friendly and understanding staff!

          Property Manager Response

          3/23/2026

          Thank you for your feedback, the Grand Opening of the gym is next week April 2nd, we hope to see you there!

          Updated Review

          Review Author Icon

          Current Resident 1348233

          Verified Resident 2025 - 2026

          4.7

          3/19/2026

          Excellent community services. The only complaint I have is that there are too many stray cats in the community, and nothing is being done to control the stray cats in the area. Otherwise, the maintenance staff works professionally and efficiently.

            Property Manager Response

            3/20/2026

            Thanks for sharing your thoughts! We re happy you ve had a good experience with our services and maintenance team. We also hear your concern about the stray cats and will take it into consideration. We appreciate you being here!

            Updated Review

            Review Author Icon

            Current Resident 1396856

            Verified Resident 2026

            5.0

            3/19/2026

            Best decision I have made moving into Carlton Arms studio.The staff is outstanding, the maintenance guys are professional, friendly and fast. It is very queit around here, the outdoors are being kept neat and clean.I enjoy living here.

              Property Manager Response

              3/20/2026

              We re so glad to hear your move to Carlton Arms has been such a great decision! It s wonderful that you re enjoying the peaceful atmosphere and well-kept surroundings. Our team takes pride in providing prompt, professional service, and your feedback truly means a lot. Thank you for being part of our community!

              Updated Review

              Review Author Icon

              Current Resident 1318507

              Verified Resident 2024 - 2026

              5.0

              3/19/2026

              Everyone at Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is super nice, I have real enjoyed living here thank you for everything you do please keep up the great work I will continue to renew my lease and stay in the most peaceful place that I have lived

                Property Manager Response

                3/20/2026

                Thank you so much for your thoughtful feedback! We re thrilled to hear how much you re enjoying your home at Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley. It means a lot that you choose to stay with us we re grateful to have you as part of our community!

                Updated Review

                Review Author Icon

                Current Resident 1236937

                Verified Resident 2018 - 2026

                5.0

                3/19/2026

                Good community and friendly staff. Decent rent for the area. Good maintenance and office staff. Well kept grounds. Good amenities. Very nice pools and new fitness center opening soon. Very good place to call home.

                  Property Manager Response

                  3/20/2026

                  Thank you! We re glad you re enjoying the community, amenities, and our team. Happy to have you here!

                  Updated Review

                  Review Author Icon

                  Current Resident 1232824

                  Verified Resident 2023 - 2026

                  5.0

                  3/18/2026

                  My time here I have had a great experience. Maintenance comes very fast. The grounds are maintained very well. They have fast service , the facilities in the complex and amenities are great. I would love to stay here for years

                    Property Manager Response

                    3/20/2026

                    Thank you for your kind feedback! We're glad you're enjoying your experience, our fast maintenance service, and the well-kept community. It means a lot to hear you'd like to stay for years we d love to have you!
                    Review Author Icon

                    Current Resident 1410954

                    Verified Resident 2019 - 2026

                    4.5

                    3/18/2026

                    The staff has always been very kind, courteous, and willing to help with anything needed for us residents, even if it is just providing proper i formation towards a question. Maintenance does a great job in responding and ensuring the task gets accomplished.

                      Property Manager Response

                      3/20/2026

                      Thank you so much for your kind words! We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. Our team works hard to provide helpful, courteous service, and it s wonderful to hear that both our staff and maintenance team have made a positive impact. We re grateful to have you as part of our community!

                      Updated Review

                      Review Author Icon

                      Current Resident 1322939

                      Verified Resident 2021 - 2026

                      5.0

                      3/13/2026

                      Is a quite and nice place to live. Maintenance issues are promptly resolved. Leasing staff are very courteous. Neighbors are overall nice people. Although I have participated in only a couple of community events, I most say those events are very nice.

                        Property Manager Response

                        3/18/2026

                        We truly appreciate your feedback, our fitness center grand opening is coming, hope to see you there!

                        Updated Review

                        Review Author Icon

                        Current Resident 1378221

                        Verified Resident 2025 - 2026

                        5.0

                        3/12/2026

                        Good community and clean community. Most tenants stick to themselves and Only issue i had was the trash can issue and looks likes it is still going on but less frequent. But other wise the apartments have been a good home and I also referraled my friend

                          Property Manager Response

                          3/12/2026

                          Thank you for your kind words, let us know what type of issue are you having with the trashcans by email and we will be happy to assist!

                          Updated Review

                          Review Author Icon

                          Current Resident 1247360

                          Verified Resident 2022 - 2026

                          5.0

                          2/26/2026

                          We had to wait a year to get in and it was so worth it! Ive always heard such good things about it and they are all true! While everyones rent gets raised by the hundreds ours has only been a few bucks every year, and with the work they put into this place, again its worth it! Nice people! Fast maintenance service! And they are ALWAYS working on something to better the grounds!

                            Property Manager Response

                            3/2/2026

                            It means a lot to know you value the care we put into the community, from keeping rent increases reasonable to continually improving the grounds. Our maintenance team will especially appreciate the shoutout for their quick service!

                            Updated Review

                            Review Author Icon

                            Current Resident 867504

                            Verified Resident 2021 - 2026

                            5.0

                            2/26/2026

                            Low cost beautiful place to live and enjoy the community great place for pets. Good staff. Great maintenance team. They work like ninjas ground are kept clean. Spacious apartment. Fun activities. Good location

                              Property Manager Response

                              3/2/2026

                              Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We re thrilled to hear you re enjoying the beautiful community, spacious apartment, and fun activities. We hope to see you in out St. Patty's Day celebration this month. ?? We re grateful to have you as part of our community.
                              Review Author Icon

                              Current Resident 1243367

                              Verified Resident 2018 - 2026

                              4.7

                              2/21/2026

                              This has been my home for the past 8-9 years. I feel safe, the neighbors are friendly and we get to know each other by name. There's a nice dog park right next to a fenced playground, which the kids love to watch the dogs run around from. The pools are well maintained and miles of sidewalks within the community. A brand new gym is currently being built and from what I have heard an additional yoga room. Even though this isn't a brand new complex it's great for Florida living. The grounds are beautiful with old oaks lining the entire landscape. Plenty of wildlife all around. Again, I'm glad this is my home ??

                                Property Manager Response

                                2/23/2026

                                Thank you for being part of our community for nearly a decade that truly means so much to us! We re so happy to hear that you feel safe and connected with your neighbors, and that you re enjoying the dog park, playground, pools, and beautiful oak-lined grounds. We re also excited about the new gym and yoga space and can t wait for everyone to enjoy them! It s wonderful to know you re proud to call this home we re grateful to have you here ??
                                Review Author Icon

                                Current Resident 1405745

                                Verified Resident 2025 - 2026

                                4.8

                                2/19/2026

                                Calm and place, good for family with kids or even elderly people. Good rent price. All staff are super nice, passionate and proud of what they do. I hope to stay here for the next years. KUDOS TO ALL THE MAINTENANCE STAFF

                                  Property Manager Response

                                  2/23/2026

                                  Your kind words about our team mean the world to us. Our staff takes great pride in what they do every day, and your recognition especially for our amazing maintenance team will absolutely make their day. We ll be sure to pass along your kudos! We re honored that you hope to stay with us for years to come. We look forward to continuing to make your experience a great one!

                                  Updated Review

                                  Review Author Icon

                                  Current Resident 1257685

                                  Verified Resident 2020 - 2026

                                  1.7

                                  2/19/2026

                                  Not happy in the help I get when there's issues. When there's no noise or maintenance issues if the resident services isn't here while it's happening then according to Carlton Arms it does not exist and I find that to be very disappointing. I have been here for almost 6 years and have paid all my rent on time every time.

                                    Property Manager Response

                                    2/19/2026

                                    Thank you for taking the time to share your concerns, and we truly appreciate your nearly six years of residency and consistent on-time payments. At Carlton Arms, we take maintenance and noise concerns seriously. Our team does rely on direct observation when possible so we can accurately assess and resolve issues, but that does not mean your experience is dismissed if staff is not present at the exact moment it occurs. We understand that some issues are intermittent and can be difficult to witness firsthand. We would welcome the opportunity to work with you more closely whether that involves documented times, recordings, or scheduling a visit during peak concern hours so we can properly investigate and address the matter. Your comfort in your home is important to us.

                                    Updated Review

                                    Review Author Icon

                                    Current Resident 1291602

                                    Verified Resident 2024 - 2026

                                    4.8

                                    2/12/2026

                                    Quiet & clean complex. Friendly staff & will help whenever needed, for any situation. No issues at all in the almost two years I've been there. Also have a friend that has been there 9 years & him & his wife love it there.

                                      Property Manager Response

                                      2/12/2026

                                      Thank you for letting us know your positive experience, Happy Valentine's Day!

                                      Updated Review

                                      Review Author Icon

                                      Current Resident 1089332

                                      Verified Resident 2023 - 2026

                                      3.5

                                      2/9/2026

                                      Wonderful place I highly recommend. Much better then the other complex we lived before. Great community at an affordable price. The office staff and maintenance staff are friendly polite and take care of any issues that may arise in a timely manor.

                                        Property Manager Response

                                        2/10/2026

                                        Thank you for your feedback!

                                        Updated Review

                                        Review Author Icon

                                        Current Resident 1378299

                                        Verified Resident 2021 - 2026

                                        5.0

                                        2/9/2026

                                        We'll keep grounds in the community. When need a work order done they send a person fast. Always send communication about community informing about activities and renters request. Good community to call home.

                                          Property Manager Response

                                          2/9/2026

                                          Thank you for those kind words. We appreciate your feedback and look forward to continuing to exceed your expectations.

                                          Updated Review

                                          Review Author Icon

                                          Current Resident 1368591

                                          Verified Resident 2017 - 2026

                                          4.7

                                          2/5/2026

                                          Always been a pleasurer to live here. Staff are responsive to all requests. The property is lovely with the lakes and the many different types of birds. Neighbors have been pleasant. Although is is quiet and secluded the apartments are close to all needed stores, schools, etc.

                                            Property Manager Response

                                            2/5/2026

                                            You made a great point about our location, we are very grateful to have you as a neighbor!
                                            Review Author Icon

                                            Current Resident 1402190

                                            Verified Resident 2025 - 2026

                                            5.0

                                            2/2/2026

                                            Clean, safe and quiet! We've been here 2 months and everything has been smooth. Facilities have all been working great, there is always someone at the gate monitoring entrances and exit and fast service. The app they use for communicating makes everything extremely easy too.

                                              Property Manager Response

                                              2/3/2026

                                              Welcome to the community, we are so happy you are enjoying your apartment and we are happy to have you here!
                                              Review Author Icon

                                              Current Resident 1402163

                                              Verified Resident 2016 - 2026

                                              5.0

                                              2/2/2026

                                              I love living at Carlton Arms Magnolia Valley. The property is always well maintained, the staff is friendly and efficient. There are lots of things to do including special events on holidays. Maintenance issues are resolved almost immediately. The staff are exceptional Lucas, Andrew, Mike, Bob, Dee just to mention a few of the remarkable team members here that make me feel safe, comfortable cared for and make Carlton Arms feel like home!

                                                Property Manager Response

                                                2/3/2026

                                                Thank you for recognizing our amazing team members, they are all a delight to work with :)
                                                Review Author Icon

                                                Current Resident 1401387

                                                Verified Resident 2025 - 2026

                                                5.0

                                                1/29/2026

                                                I really like living here. I've always thought the community looked beautiful from driving by in passing. It's pretty quiet and no one really bothers you. Most of the guys working the gate are friendly, and the same goes for the maintenance guys. If you put in a service request the night before, they will usually get to it the next day.

                                                  Property Manager Response

                                                  1/30/2026

                                                  Thank you for the kind review! We re so happy to hear you re enjoying the community and the peaceful atmosphere. It s great to know our gate and maintenance teams have been helpful and friendly. We re glad to have you here!

                                                  Floor Plans & Pricing

                                                  1 Bedroom

                                                  1 Bed, 1 Bath

                                                  $1,205

                                                  See Floor Plan Details

                                                  1 Bed, 1.5 Baths

                                                  $2,127

                                                  See Floor Plan Details

                                                  2 Bedrooms

                                                  2 Beds, 2 Baths

                                                  $1,327

                                                  See Floor Plan Details

                                                  2 Beds, 2.5 Baths

                                                  $1,489

                                                  See Floor Plan Details

                                                  2 Beds, 1.5 Baths

                                                  $2,032

                                                  See Floor Plan Details

                                                  Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

                                                  epIQ Ratings

                                                  What is epIQ?

                                                  The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

                                                  epIQ Report Card

                                                  In partnership with SatisFacts™

                                                  Community epIQ Grade

                                                  A+
                                                  A+

                                                  Renter Ratings

                                                  A

                                                  Review Ratings (from 115 reviews)

                                                  Noise

                                                  4.8

                                                  Grounds

                                                  4.8

                                                  Safety

                                                  4.8

                                                  Office Staff

                                                  4.9

                                                  Maintenance

                                                  4.9

                                                  Neighborhood

                                                  4.8

                                                  Survey Scores (from 1145 surveys)

                                                  Post-Tour Survey

                                                  4.7

                                                  Move-In Survey

                                                  4.8

                                                  Maintenance & Support Survey

                                                  4.8

                                                  Lease Renewal Survey

                                                  4.7

                                                  Review Count

                                                  A+

                                                  Number of reviews in the past 365 days

                                                  115

                                                  Manager’s Review Engagement

                                                  A+

                                                  Percentage of reviews responded to

                                                  100.00%

                                                  Manager’s Review Reply Time

                                                  A+

                                                  Average time to respond to reviews

                                                  1.74 days

                                                  Features & Amenities

                                                  Laundry
                                                  • In-Unit Washer/Dryer
                                                  • Laundry Facilities
                                                  • Laundry On-Site
                                                  • Washer/Dryer Connections
                                                  Parking
                                                  • Parking
                                                  Pets
                                                  • Cats Allowed
                                                  • Dogs Allowed
                                                  Other
                                                  • Air Conditioning
                                                  • Balcony/Deck
                                                  • Cat Friendly
                                                  • Community Center
                                                  • Controlled Access
                                                  • Dishwasher
                                                  • Fitness Center
                                                  • Large Dog Friendly
                                                  • On-site Personnel
                                                  • Pool/Hot Tub
                                                  Show Less
                                                  Show More
                                                  This community is managed by

                                                  The Mahaffey Company

                                                  A+
                                                  A+
                                                  Communities
                                                  13

                                                  Questions & Answers (1)

                                                  Anonymous
                                                  Asked on: 03/19/2018
                                                  Q: How easy is it to find guest parking?

                                                  Frequently Asked

                                                  How is Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley Rated?
                                                  Based on 1574 number of votes by renters, Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is currently rated 4.7 out of 5 stars.
                                                  How satisfied are residents with the upkeep and overall appearance of the grounds at Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley?
                                                  Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered excellent. The grounds are well kept and beautiful.
                                                  How effective was the maintenance team when resolving your problem?
                                                  Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is rated 4.9 out of 5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered excellent. The maintenance team is very responsive and effective in addressing issues.
                                                  What are noise levels like at Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley?
                                                  Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered excellent. The noise level is consistently low and does not cause any disturbances.
                                                  How safe is Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley?
                                                  Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is very secure and safe, with no major safety concerns.
                                                  How satisfied are residents with the neighborhood?
                                                  Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is located in a very desirable and safe neighborhood with convenient access to local attractions and services.
                                                  How satisfied are residents with the staff at Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley?
                                                  Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is rated 4.9 out of 5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered excellent. The staff is extremely helpful and responsive to resident needs.
                                                  How often does management engage with reviews?
                                                  Managers have responded to 100% of their community reviews in the past year.
                                                  How quickly does management engage with reviews?
                                                  Managers have replied within 1.74 days to their community reviews in the past year.
                                                  Who manages Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley?
                                                  The Mahaffey Company
                                                  What is the pet policy at Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley?
                                                  Cats Allowed
                                                  Dogs Allowed
                                                  What types of floor plans are available?
                                                  1 Bed, 1 Bath
                                                  1 Bed, 1.5 Baths
                                                  2 Beds, 1.5 Baths
                                                  2 Beds, 2 Baths
                                                  2 Beds, 2.5 Baths

                                                  Contact Property

                                                  Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley

                                                  March 2026

                                                  Sun
                                                  Mon
                                                  Tue
                                                  Wed
                                                  Thu
                                                  Fri
                                                  Sat
                                                  1
                                                  2
                                                  3
                                                  4
                                                  5
                                                  6
                                                  7
                                                  8
                                                  9
                                                  10
                                                  11
                                                  12
                                                  13
                                                  14
                                                  15
                                                  16
                                                  17
                                                  18
                                                  19
                                                  20
                                                  21
                                                  22
                                                  23
                                                  24
                                                  25
                                                  26
                                                  27
                                                  28
                                                  29
                                                  30
                                                  31
                                                  Beds

                                                  0

                                                  Baths

                                                  0

                                                  Under New Management

                                                  Claim your community to update listing information, capture leads, and respond to reviews!

                                                  Carlton Arms of Magnolia Valley is an apartment in New Port Richey in zip code 34653. This community has a 1 - 2 Beds, 1 - 2.5 Baths, and is for rent for $1,205 - $2,127. Nearby cities include Trinity, Port Richey, Holiday, Tarpon Springs, Hudson, Palm Harbor, Land O' Lakes, Oldsmar, Land O Lakes, Dunedin, Lutz, Safety Harbor, and Spring Hill.